Hot topics and trends in corporate restructuring
The Deloitte CRG Newsletter addresses the current state and outlook for the CRG practice, including recent engagements, announcements, case studies, and upcoming events.
CRG December: A year in perspective
A year ago we wrote that it was difficult to tell whether the economy was recovering or still struggling–as 2014 draws to a close, it would seem that we are indeed returning to growth mode, with gross domestic product growth at 3.9% for the third quarter and a combined 4.25% through the six months ended September 30. Less clear is whether the sudden drop in oil prices will on balance help or hurt.
Consumers may have more in their pocket to spend, but on the other hand much of our recent economic growth has been driven by the energy sector. Regardless, whatever salutary impact lower energy costs do have on total consumer spending, recent Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data suggests the retail, restaurants, apparel/textiles, and other consumer-oriented sectors may not see as much of a boost as we might presume. The steady upward march of healthcare costs and other necessities over the last several years is crowding out discretionary spending.
According to analysis of BLS data by the Wall Street Journal, for the middle class–defined as having annual income between $18,000 and $95,000 before taxes, i.e., the “middle 60%” by income–not only have incomes stagnated, growing less than half a percent between 2007 and 2013, versus inflation of 12% over the period, total healthcare spending is up 24%. Insurance premiums alone are up a shocking (or not) 42%. Groceries, rent, education, and especially digital connectivity (cell phones, cable/satellite TV, internet access) are up significantly as well. With total spending only up 2.3% over the period, the math seems clear–non-essentials remain under pressure despite growth in the larger economy. It may cost less to fill up at the pump, but those savings may already be spoken for. Furthermore, keep in mind that this data pre-dates the Affordable Care Act (ACA), which will likely drive healthcare spending higher as more households obtain health insurance. The newly enrolled may have to cut spending back elsewhere as they pay insurance premiums for the first time.
In our practice, energy-related engagements are of course increasing, particularly in Exploration & Production and Oilfield Services & Equipment, but we are also hearing rumblings in the retail and consumer sectors, and expect to see more activity there in the coming year. Even healthcare providers are seeking our assistance as the implementation of ACA disrupts the “normal” flow of reimbursements and minimum wage hikes in various jurisdictions create cost pressure.
Wherever our work takes us over the next year, to the oil patch, the shopping mall, or somewhere else, and whether involving complex restructurings or targeted performance improvement, we look forward to a busy 2015, and thank all of you who have supported our practice in 2014 and in years past. Deloitte CRG wishes you and yours the Happiest of Holidays and a prosperous New Year.
Building products manufacturer & distributor
Deloitte CRG currently serves as an operational improvement advisor to a Canadian building products manufacturer and distributor. Facing seasonality, SKU proliferation and rapid growth, the company engaged Deloitte CRG to improve its supply chain processes, systems and tools in order to improve customer service, inventory turns and profitability.
Following a series of failed joint ventures, the loss of a significant contract, and a significant outflow of cash to buy out private shareholders, a middle market steel fabricator found itself without liquidity. The company, led by an interim CFO and an investment bank was forced to file bankruptcy without counsel. Two months later, after efforts to negotiate a plan with the secured lender proved unsuccessful, Deloitte CRG was retained by the unsecured trade vendors to assist in its evaluation of the debtors restructuring efforts and plan. Deloitte CRG has taken a lead role in the negotiation efforts, and is working with the debtors to creatively secure additional working capital.
Healthcare technology company
Deloitte CRG currently serves as the financial advisor to the company on exiting select non-core product lines that resulted from a merger. Deloitte CRG is assisting in developing the plan to reduce cost, accelerate project completion dates and preserve client relationships. Deloitte CRG is also assisting in developing carve-out and stand-alone plans for a separate non-core product line to be effectuated at year end.
Explore additional noteworthy engagements at the CRG featured engagements page.
New chapter for innovative retailer
After a disappointing holiday season, Brookstone fell into default with their senior lender and was close to default on their second lien bond debt. The specialty retailer was under enormous pressure to resolve their balance sheet challenges immediately. While the company's first lien lender seemed comfortably secured by assets, it was unclear how other creditors would fare if the situation worsened. As a result, the lenders turned up the heat on the company to sell itself very fast, a process that most likely would have reduced recoveries even further. Instead, by working quickly, Deloitte CRG bought time for Brookstone's investment banker to execute on a sale process in a reasonable time frame to a strategic buyer, avoiding a 'fire sale' and yielding a far better outcome for all parties. Not only did the senior lender get paid in full, the second lien bondholder's recovery is significantly higher than originally anticipated, the company and brand will continue intact with few, if any, projected store closures, and the vendors will be largely uncompromised.
Working closely with management, the Deloitte CRG team first put together a credible weekly financial picture that reassured the senior secured lender there was sufficient time to run an expedited sale process. The investment banker, with Deloitte CRG's close support, signed up a stalking horse bidder for a plan of reorganization. Deloitte CRG, along with Brookstone's investment banker and bankruptcy counsel, then assisted Brookstone management through negotiations over a pre-arranged bankruptcy filing and developed a Plan contemplating a stock sale through an auction process that yielded an Enterprise Value of approximately $173 million (17x FY 2013 EBITDA). The successful sale process not only rescued the company, it saved over 3,000 jobs.
Transactions & Business Events
Anticipating tomorrow’s complex issues and new strategies is a challenge. Reach new heights with Dbriefs—live webcasts that give you valuable insights on important developments affecting your business.Dbriefs offers live webcasts featuring practical knowledge from Deloitte specialists.
Life at Deloitte
People make Deloitte one of the best places to work. What’s great about the people? That’s an easy answer. They are exceptional. Each person is unique and valued for that, among the best and brightest in the business, and takes pride in his or her achievements and the success of others.