The emergence of blockchain consortia | Deloitte Insights
Deloitte
  • Services
    What's New
    • 2019 Global Human Capital Trends

      Leading the social enterprise: Reinvent with human focus

    • Deloitte Reimagine Platform

      Tapping the power of SAP® Leonardo to launch the digital enterprise

    • Future of Work

      Disruption lies ahead

    Audit & Assurance
    • IASPlus
    Consulting
    • Strategy, Analytics and M&A
    • Customer and Marketing
    • Core Business Operations
    • Human Capital
    • Enterprise Technology & Performance
    Risk Advisory
    • Strategic & Reputation Risk
    • Regulatory Risk
    • Financial Risk
    • Operational Risk
    • Cyber Risk
    Financial Advisory
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Restructuring Services
    • Deloitte Forensic
    Legal
    • Deloitte Legal around the world
    • Dbriefs Legal
    • Deloitte Legal services
    Tax
    • Global Business Tax
    • Global Employer Services
    • Global Tax Reset
    • Tax Automation and AI
  • Industries
    What's New
    • Deloitte perspectives

      Leadership perspectives from across the globe.

    • Future of Mobility

      Learn how this new reality is coming together and what it will mean for you and your industry.

    • Platforms and Ecosystems

      Enabling the Digital Economy

    Consumer
    • Automotive
    • Consumer Products
    • Retail, Wholesale & Distribution
    • Transportation, Hospitality & Services
    Energy, Resources & Industrials
    • Industrial Products & Construction
    • Mining & Metals
    • Oil, Gas & Chemicals
    • Power & Utilities
    • Future of Energy
    Financial Services
    • Banking & Capital Markets
    • Insurance
    • Investment Management
    • Real Estate
    Government & Public Services
    • Civil Government
    • Defense, Security & Justice
    • Health & Social Care
    • International Donor Organizations
    • Transport
    Life Sciences & Health Care
    • Health Care
    • Life Sciences
    Technology, Media & Telecommunications
    • Technology
    • Telecommunications, Media & Entertainment
  • Insights

    Deloitte Insights
    What's New
    • Daily executive briefing

      Timely insights to inform your agenda.

    • Deloitte Review

      Looking ahead, staying ahead

    • Deloitte Insights app

      Get daily updates on your mobile device

    By topic
    • AI & cognitive technologies
    • Analytics
    • Blockchain
    • Digital transformation
    • Diversity & inclusion
    • Economics
    • Human capital
    • Innovation
    • Leadership
    • Private companies
    • Risk management
    • Strategy
    By sector
    • Automotive
    • Consumer products & retail
    • Financial services
    • Government & public services
    • Health care
    • Industrial products
    • Life sciences
    • Oil, gas & chemicals
    • Power & utilities
    • Technology
    • Telecom, media & entertainment
    • Transportation & hospitality
    Spotlight
    • Daily Executive Briefing
    • Deloitte Review
    • Economic weekly update
    • Future of mobility
    • Future of work
    • Industry 4.0
    • Internet of Things
    • Smart cities
  • Careers
    What's New
    • Millennial Survey 2019

      Optimism and trust reach troubling low levels

    • Alumni profiles

      Inspiring leaders

    Job search
    Experienced hires
    Students
    Life at Deloitte
    Alumni
  • GLOBAL-EN Location: GLOBAL-English  
    • Contact us
    • GLOBAL-EN Location: GLOBAL-English  
      • Contact us

      Banding together for blockchain

      By Peter Gratzke, David Schatsky, Eric Piscini
      • Add to my bookmarks
      • Highlight
      • Download
      • Share
        • Share on Facebook
        • Share on Twitter
        • Share on Linkedin
        • Share by email
      Deloitte Insights
      • By topic
        By topic
        By topic
        • AI & cognitive technologies
        • Analytics
        • Blockchain
        • Digital transformation
        • Diversity & inclusion
        • Economics
        • Human capital
        • Innovation
        • Leadership
        • Private companies
        • Risk management
        • Strategy
      • By sector
        By sector
        By sector
        • Automotive
        • Consumer products & retail
        • Financial services
        • Government & public services
        • Health care
        • Industrial products
        • Life sciences
        • Oil, gas & chemicals
        • Power & utilities
        • Technology
        • Telecom, media & entertainment
        • Transportation & hospitality
      • Spotlight
        Spotlight
        Spotlight
        • Daily Executive Briefing
        • Deloitte Review
        • Economic weekly update
        • Future of mobility
        • Future of work
        • Industry 4.0
        • Internet of Things
        • Smart cities
      • GLOBAL-EN Location: GLOBAL-English  
        • Contact us
        16 August 2017

        Banding together for blockchain Does it make sense for your company to join a consortium?

        16 August 2017
        • Peter Gratzke
        • David Schatsky
        • Eric Piscini
        • Add to my bookmarks
        • Highlight
        • Download
        • Share
          • Share on Facebook
          • Share on Twitter
          • Share on Linkedin
          • Share by email
        • Signals
        • The emergence of blockchain consortia
        • Where blockchain consortia are heading
        • Next steps for companies

        Blockchain is a technology that requires collaboration to be effective, which is why companies—both allies and competitors—have begun working together in consortia. But creating a successful blockchain consortium requires planning, investment, and commitment.​

        Learn more

        Explore the Signals for Strategists collection

        Some technologies—say, spreadsheets or photo-editing software—are valuable in the hands of a single user. Others require buy-in from many users, both partners and competitors, with their value increasing as more parties sign on.

        Blockchain—the digital distributed ledger technology that underpins Bitcoin and promises to transform so many industries—is evolving rapidly.1 But one blockchain trend is not particularly technological in nature: A growing number of companies that are seeking to develop and deploy business solutions based on blockchain technology are pursuing their goals as part of a consortium, which is a group of companies that join together, typically to set standards to enable the development of new infrastructures.

        Distributed ledgers are business-to-business workflow tools, which entails that blockchain practically demands collaboration—to set standards, develop infrastructure, and execute transactions. And these consortia are the mechanism through which blockchain-interested companies, regulators, and governments are collaborating. Some consortia—most notably in financial services—seem on track to succeed. But not all are set up for success.

        Any company seeking to capitalize on blockchain’s potential to increase operational efficiency and enable new business models and client solutions should consider joining or forming a blockchain consortium while heeding the lessons from the first generation of consortia. In particular, adequate funding, robust governance, and commitment from key companies are critical.

        Signals

        • More than 40 consortia have been formed globally—most of them in the past six months—to explore blockchain and distributed ledger technology.2
        • Well-funded and -staffed consortia that have attracted leading industry players, such as R3, have committed to deploying blockchain technology at commercial scale within the next 12 months.3
        • While most consortia thus far are in financial services, other industries, including health care4 and logistics, have begun following suit.5
        • Policymakers, regulators, and central banks are beginning to join or found and lead blockchain consortia.6
        • Among executives knowledgeable about blockchain technology, 18 percent already participate in a consortium, 45 percent are likely to join one, and 14 percent are considering forming one.7

        The emergence of blockchain consortia

        Consortia have become a popular means for enterprises to work together on blockchain technology. More than 40 blockchain consortia have formed globally, some of which have attracted significant investments,8 mostly from industry players in financial services, including Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Citigroup, Credit Suisse, Goldman Sachs, and JP Morgan.9

        There are two types of blockchain consortia: business-focused and technology-focused. Business-focused consortia aim to build and operate blockchain-based business platforms to solve a specific business problem. An example is Digital Trade Chain, launched in January 2017 by seven leading European banks and focusing on “building a blockchain-based platform design to facilitate cross-border trade for small and medium-sized businesses”; the consortium’s members include Deutsche Bank, Société Générale, Rabobank, and UniCredit, who all agreed to collaborate and fund the development of the new platform.10 Deloitte has also been working with the Hong Kong Monetary Authority and the leading trade finance banks in Hong Kong to develop a Distributed Ledger Technology proof of concept for Trade Finance.11

        Technology-focused consortia seek to develop reusable blockchain platforms based on technical standards. An example is Hyperledger, an “open source collaborative effort created to advance cross-industry blockchain technologies.” Members include leading companies in finance, banking, logistics, and manufacturing, such as SAP, IBM, Intel, Fujitsu, and Daimler.12 The consortium recently released its first production-ready platform, Fabric, with a modular architecture that allows users to plug and play components such as consensus and membership services.13

        Some consortia cover both types of activities. An example is R3, whose consortium includes more than 80 of the world’s largest financial institutions, regulators, and central banks. The consortium has announced an intention to release a stable version of its platform, Corda, in Q3 2017, with an enterprise offering following later.

        Why consortia are critical for blockchain technology in enterprise

        Why do companies join blockchain consortia? For some, consortia represent a low-risk effort to stay current on blockchain trends, learn what competitors are doing, defend against potential new threats, and prepare to implement the technology should they decide to. In the view of some industry analysts, many companies are joining consortia for FOMO: fear of missing out.14

        Ultimately, blockchain consortia form as a consequence of the technology itself. Although a distributed ledger can have an immediate positive impact even between two businesses, it derives more utility from network effects: The greater the number of users, the more valuable the technology is to all of them. Consortia allow companies to take advantage of blockchain network effects from day one, by providing a vehicle to create a governance structure around this collaboration, often among players that compete against one other. Consequently, in order to use blockchain effectively, most enterprises need to be part of a consortium.

        Where blockchain consortia are heading

        Number of consortia by sector

        The financial services industry has more blockchain consortia than any other. But we expect other industries to begin forming consortia as well; we already see movement in health care15 and logistics,16 with anticipated new consortia in pharmacy RX fulfillment and genomics data management, among other use cases.17 In addition, we can expect governments and regulators to begin playing a significant role in blockchain consortia.

        Strategies for consortia aiming to deploy blockchain at commercial scale

        In examining the progress that consortia have made to date, four success factors stand out.

        First is funding. Applying blockchain technology to a business use case and bringing it into production requires significant investment in technical talent and several years’ worth of commitment to technical implementation. Only one consortium has raised significant funding: R3 has brought in more than $100 million from existing members,18 allowing it to invest heavily in building technology without having to rely solely on membership fees.

        Second is membership. Some industry consortia are succeeding thanks to the commitment of industry leaders. For example, Fundchain, an international consortium of asset managers, is working to bring 401(k) plans, mutual funds, and pension funds to the blockchain. After rolling out a smart transfer agent proof-of-concept in December 2016, the consortium—comprising leaders in the industry—is targeting the release of an initial product for 2018.19 B3i, a consortium comprising insurance industry leaders, is leveraging blockchain to swap information and collaboratively test prototypes and use cases. A prototype is expected to undergo testing, with a plan to publish the results this year, and the insurers have an eye on spinning that platform off into a separate company as early as 2018.20

        Third is leadership. Some consortia have made significant progress thanks to the outsized commitment of a single leading player. In the case of Hyperledger, IBM is providing a significant part of the codebase,21 while the technology of one of the versions of the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance is based on Quorum, an open-source project led by JPMorgan.22

        Fourth is governance. Consortia need good governance structures to facilitate consensus around standardization issues that are in part driven by politics. Convincing competitors to collaborate is no easy feat. In interviews with leading consortia, we encountered a number of different approaches, including the formation of smaller subgroups to work on delineated issues, and providing several levels of potential engagement, ranging from participation in monthly calls to active technology development.23 Consortia with good governance structures in place are the ones capable of getting traditional competitors to collaborate and work together.

        Next steps for companies

        Industry players should be clear about their goals when contemplating joining a blockchain consortium. Joining to study and explore blockchain technology is a very different commitment from aggressively moving to build and deploy the technology at commercial scale. In the latter case, executives should assess potential consortium participation according to the factors enumerated above. Last, companies have the opportunity to be a leader in innovation and create a new business consortium, as opposed to joining one. This is harder, but the rewards can be higher, as companies can monetize the platform over time.

        Intermediaries (third parties who provide a service to facilitate transactions between buyers and sellers of a product or service) that are active in high-potential areas for blockchain applications have an opportunity to monitor and shape a potentially disruptive technology; they should consider playing a major role in an industry consortium. In the securities industry, a number of clearinghouses—intermediaries between buyers and sellers of financial instruments—have joined the Post Trade Distributed Ledger Working Group to pursue this path. A strategic commitment may help intermediaries preempt their clients from forming a consortium that could replace them.

        Blockchain vendors catering to enterprises will face challenges and opportunities with the growth of consortia. Securing a consortium’s business can capture a big segment of the market—and many vendors are following a consortium go-to-market strategy in order to lock in customers early. On the other hand, if a competitor succeeds in building a minimum viable ecosystem with a consortium, picking off individual players represents an uphill battle. First-mover advantage can play a significant role in a consortium-dominated demand-side landscape.

        Banding together for success

        Consortia will play a central role in the commercialization of blockchain technology in every industry. We can expect dozens more consortia to form in the next two or three years. Not all will lead to commercial deployments, and this is fine for members that are more interested in learning at this stage. Companies with serious commercial intent will want to consider the funding, membership, leadership, and governance of the consortia they join.

        Credits

        Written by: Peter Gratzke, David Schatsky, Eric Piscini

        Cover image by: Molly Woodworth

        Acknowledgements

        Ramya Kunnath Puliyakodil of Deloitte Support Services India Pvt Ltd.; Alexander Kuck and Tanmoy Jadhav of Deloitte LLP; Thomas Jankovich of Deloitte Consulting LLP; Robert Massey of Deloitte Tax LLP; Peter Evans-Greenwood, Ian Harper, Robert Hillard, Jonathan Perkinson of Deloitte Australia; Andrew Keys of ConsenSys; and Antony Lewis of R3.

        Endnotes
          1. For an overview of the impact blockchain is having across industries, see /content/www/global/en/insights/focus/signals-for-strategists/trends-blockchain-bitcoin-security-transparency.html. View in article

          2. Deloitte analysis. View in article

          3. Deloitte interviews with leading consortia. View in article

          4. For example, Hashed Health, https://hashedhealth.com/, accessed August 6, 2017. View in article

          5. Global Trade, “Dutch logistics consortium to explore blockchain technology,” December 30, 2016, http://go.shr.lc/2inrLl7. View in article

          6. Carlo R.W. De Meijer, “Blockchain Project Jasper: Reaching boundaries,” Finextra, February 15, 2017, www.finextra.com/blogposting/13707/blockchain-project-jasper-reaching-boundaries. View in article

          7. Deloitte blockchain US executive survey, conducted December 2016; n = 308. View in article

          8. Deloitte interviews with leading consortia. View in article

          9. For example, Digital Asset, Crunchbase, www.crunchbase.com/organization/digital-asset-2#/entity, and R3, Crunchbase, www.crunchbase.com/organization/r3-cev#/entity; both accessed August 6, 2017. View in article

          10. Alexander Lielacher, “Blockchain consortia are paving the way for adoption in financial services,” BTC Manager, March 15, 2017, https://btcmanager.com/smaller-blockchain-consortia-pave-the-way-for-adoption/. View in article

          11. Deloitte, “Deloitte, HKMA and leading trade finance banks in Hong Kong have developed a Distributed Ledger Technology proof of concept for Trade Finance,” March 30, 2017, https://www2.deloitte.com/cn/en/pages/about-deloitte/articles/pr-deloitte-hkma-dlt-proof-of-concept-for-trade-finance.htm. View in article

          12. Hyperledger, www.hyperledger.org/about, accessed August 6, 2017. View in article

          13. Tom Groenfeldt, “Linux Foundat’s Hyperledger Fabric 1.0 ready for production,” Forbes, July 13, 2017, www.forbes.com/sites/tomgroenfeldt/2017/07/13/linux-foundats-hyperledger-fabric-1-0-ready-for-production/. View in article

          14. Dan DeFrancesco, “The DTCC’s fear of missing out on the blockchain,” WatersTechnology, January 27, 2016, www.waterstechnology.com/2443641. View in article

          15. Hashed Health. View in article

          16. Global Trade, “Dutch logistics consortium to explore blockchain technology.” View in article

          17. Rajarshi Sengupta and Lakshman Shankar, Blockchain—revolutionary change or not?, Deloitte, 2017, https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/in/Documents/strategy/in-strategy-innovation-blockchain-revolutionary-change-noexp.pdf. View in article

          18. Jonathan Shieber, “Blockchain consortium R3 raises $107 million,” TechCrunch, May 23, 2017, http://tcrn.ch/2rdz0TC. View in article

          19. Aaron Stanley, “Managed fund titans eye 2018 for blockchain MVP launch,” CoinDesk, April 3, 2017, http://bit.ly/2un9T1b. View in article

          20. Stan Higgins, “Blockchain insurance consortium B3i adds 3 new members,” CoinDesk, February 6, 2017, http://bit.ly/2umKmoK. View in article

          21. Jeffrey Borek, “Open blockchain initiative and the Linux Foundation Hyperledger Project,” IBM, February 22, 2016, https://developer.ibm.com/open/2016/02/22/ibm-open-blockchain-initiative-and-the-linux-foundation-hyperledger-project/. View in article

          22. Robert Hackett, “Big business giants from Microsoft to J.P. Morgan are getting behind Ethereum,” Fortune, February 28, 2017, http://for.tn/2mxWf5p. View in article

          23. Deloitte interviews with leading consortia. View in article

        Show moreShow less

        Topics in this article

        Blockchain , Signals for Strategists , Technology , Emerging technologies

        Deloitte Consulting

        View
        Download Subscribe

        Related

        img Trending

        Interactive 3 days ago

        Share article highlights

        See something interesting? Simply select text and choose how to share it:

        Email a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
        Copy a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
        Copy your highlighted text.

        Banding together for blockchain has been added to your bookmarks.

        Banding together for blockchain has been removed from your bookmarks.

        An article titled Banding together for blockchain already exists in the bookmark library

         

        Connect Accounts

        Connect your social accounts

        This is the first time you have logged in with a social network.

        You have previously logged in with a different account. To link your accounts, please re-authenticate.

        Log in with an existing social network:

        To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

        OR

        Log in with an existing site account:

        To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

        Forgot password

        Subscribe

        to receive more business insights, analysis, and perspectives from Deloitte Insights
        ✓ Link copied to clipboard
        • Contact us
        • Submit RFP
        • Job search
        Follow Deloitte Insights:
        Global Office Directory
        Office Locations
        Location: GLOBAL-EN GLOBAL-English  
          About Deloitte
          • Newsroom
          • Social media
          • Leadership blog
          • Press releases
          • Submit an RFP
          • Job Search
          • Global office directory
          • Contact us

          Services

          • Audit & Assurance
          • Consulting
          • Risk Advisory
          • Financial Advisory
          • Legal
          • Tax

          Industries

          • Consumer
          • Energy, Resources & Industrials
          • Financial Services
          • Government & Public Services
          • Life Sciences & Health Care
          • Technology, Media & Telecommunications

          Careers

          • Job search
          • Experienced hires
          • Students
          • Life at Deloitte
          • Alumni
          • About Deloitte
          • Terms of use
          • Cookies
          • Privacy
          • Privacy Shield
          • Accessibility statement

           

          © 2019. For information, contact Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited.

           

          Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited (“DTTL”), its global network of member firms, and their related entities. DTTL (also referred to as “Deloitte Global”) and each of its member firms are legally separate and independent entities. DTTL does not provide services to clients. Please see www.deloitte.com/about to learn more.