Immigration reform: A competitive imperative | Deloitte Insights
  • Industries
    Industries
    • Aerospace & defense
    • Automotive
    • Financial services
    • Government & public services
    • Health care
    • Higher education
    • Life sciences
    • Manufacturing
    • Oil, gas & chemicals
    • Power & utilities
    • Retail & consumer products
    • Technology
    • Telecom, media & entertainment
  • Topics
    Topics
    BUSINESS FUNCTIONS
    • Analytics
    • Digital transformation
    • Diversity & inclusion
    • Innovation
    • Leadership
    • Marketing & sales
    • Operations
    • Risk management
    • Social impact
    • Strategy
    • Talent
    • View all
    Special Focus
    • Additive manufacturing
    • AI & cognitive technologies
    • Behavioral economics & management
    • Blockchain
    • Emerging technologies
    • Future of mobility
    • Future of work
    • Industry 4.0
    • Internet of things
    • Millennials
    • View all
    Series
    • CIO Insider
    • Executive Transitions
    • Human Capital Trends
    • Patterns of disruption
    • Signals for Strategists
    • Tech Trends
  • Economics
    Economics
    • Global home
    • Weekly Global Economic Update
    REGIONS
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe, the Middle East, Africa
    SERIES
    • Economics Spotlight
    • Issues by the Numbers
    • US Economic Forecast
    • Voice of Asia
  • Multimedia
    Multimedia
    EXPLORE
    • Infographics
    • Interactives
    • Press Room podcasts
    • Videos
    LEARN
    • Additive manufacturing course
    • Cognitive technology course
    • Dbriefs webcasts
    • Following the digital thread
  • Deloitte Review
    Deloitte Review
    • Latest issue
    • Past issues
  • Regions
    Regions
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe, the Middle East, Africa
    • Dashboard
    • Bookmarks
    • Content feed
    • Subscriptions
    • Profile/Interests
    • Account settings
  • Join | Log in
  • My Deloitte

Log in to add and see bookmarks

Still not a member? Join My Deloitte

Immigration reform: A competitive imperative

By Dr. Patricia Buckley
  • Add to my bookmarks
  • Highlight
  • Share
    • Share on Facebook
    • Share on Twitter
    • Share on Linkedin
    • Share by email
May 15, 2013

Immigration reform: A competitive imperative

May 15, 2013
  • Dr. Patricia Buckley
  • Add to my bookmarks
  • Highlight
  • Share
    • Share on Facebook
    • Share on Twitter
    • Share on Linkedin
    • Share by email

Other countries have realized that they are in a worldwide competition for talent and have adjusted their immigration policies to improve their competitiveness—the United States can do no less.

In the first installment of our new quarterly feature Issues by the Numbers, “How immigration is shaping the United States,” we detailed how immigration contributes to the economic vitality and competitiveness of the United States by making us smarter, stronger, and younger. However, the limitations of our immigration system, coupled with increased global competition for top talent, threaten this advantage. Instead of actively marketing the United States as the best place to work or grow a business, our current policies send the opposite message—and we are seeing the results in an erosion of our leadership position in science and technology.

One sign of this erosion can be seen in the substantial shift that has occurred in the balance between R&D employment by US companies abroad and R&D employment by foreign firms in the United States. According to the National Science Foundation:

  • Whereas R&D employment abroad by US multinational companies (MNCs) nearly doubled between 2004 and 2009, domestic R&D employment by these firms increased by less than 5 percent in the same period.
  • US MNCs employed many more R&D workers in foreign locations in 2009 than the number of R&D workers employed by foreign firms in the United States. In contrast, these two numbers had been similar in 2004.1

In short, US firms are sending more of their R&D jobs abroad, and those jobs are not being replaced by foreign firms establishing R&D facilities in the United States. Even if the ownership of the intellectual property being created remains US-owned, we are contributing to the technological capacity of other nations—in terms of human capital as well as the physical capital of structures and equipment—at the expense of domestic capacity.

The fact that US firms find it easier to access highly skilled R&D workers outside the United States than at home is due, in part, to our immigration policies. Granted, many multinational companies find it more cost-effective to hire foreign R&D talent. However, we cannot ignore the challenge of finding qualified workers to fill home-bound R&D positions.

Most industrialized countries already admit a higher proportion of more highly skilled immigrants than does the United States, and many are making additional changes to their immigration laws to encourage still more highly skilled workers to relocate.2 Further, many countries are investing in their science and technology capabilities, in large part by investing heavily in education and research facilities.3 Top students and researchers are finding that obtaining a world-class education or conducting cutting-edge research does not necessarily require attending a US university or working in a US-based lab.

The US immigration system is a disjointed patchwork of programs, each seeking to support a specific goal such as increasing diversity, unifying families, or filling talent gaps. The net result is a siloed system that does not serve any group well. There are huge backlogs in some immigration categories, where the wait for entry can stretch over decades; shortages in other categories, where annual caps are reached within a few days or months into the fiscal year; and regular surpluses in still other categories. Further, the time delays involved in the temporary categories frustrate employers who need to match workers with the work within tight time constraints.

Given the shortcomings of the current system, it is not surprising that there is a growing recognition of the need to enact comprehensive reforms. We should take this opportunity to redesign the system to increase flexibility and efficiency, better serving those who wish to become Americans and optimizing the potential of these new citizens to contribute to a strong shared future. We need to build on the ways that immigration makes the United States smarter, stronger, and younger. Other countries have realized that they are in a worldwide competition for talent and have adjusted their immigration policies to improve their competitiveness—the United States can do no less.

Credits

Written by: Dr. Patricia Buckley

Endnotes
    1. National Science Board, “Science and engineering indicators 2012,” National Science Foundation,  http://nsf.gov/statistics/seind12/c0/c0i.htm, accessed May 8, 2013. View in article
    2. OECD, International Migration Outlook 2012, OECD Publishing, 2012, http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/migr_outlook-2012-en. View in article
    3. National Science Board, “Science and engineering indicators 2012.” View in article
Show moreShow less

Topics in this article

United States (U.S.) , Talent

Deloitte Consulting

Learn more
Download Subscribe

Related

img Trending

Interactive 3 days ago

Share article highlights

See something interesting? Simply select text and choose how to share it:

Email a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
Copy a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
Copy your highlighted text.

Immigration reform: A competitive imperative has been added to your bookmarks.

Immigration reform: A competitive imperative has been removed from your bookmarks.

An article titled Immigration reform: A competitive imperative already exists in the bookmark library

Forgot Password

OR

social login not available on Microsoft Edge browser at this time.

Connect Accounts

Connect your social accounts

This is the first time you have logged in with a social network.

You have previously logged in with a different account. To link your accounts, please re-authenticate.

Log in with an existing social network:

To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

OR

Log in with an existing site account:

To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

Forgot password

Subscribe

to receive more business insights, analysis, and perspectives from Deloitte Insights
✓ Link copied to clipboard
  • About Deloitte Insights
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us
  • Deloitte.com
  • Careers
Follow us