Digital supply chain in retail and consumer goods
Using digital supply networks to gain competitive advantage
Retailers and consumer packaged goods companies are struggling to keep pace with increasing customer and consumer expectations of having whatever they want, whenever and wherever. Consider 10 supply chain capabilities enabled by digital supply networks (DSN) that can help retailers and CPGs alike fulfill the customer-driven shopping experience while achieving competitive differentiation and profitable growth.
Retail digital supply chain: Facing an omnichannel customer-driven landscape
Retailers today are facing a strong imperative in an increasingly customer-centric world: transform your supply chains or risk the possibility of becoming obsolete. The “everything is convenient” expectation of shopping is becoming an ever-increasing challenge for retailers to deliver upon, as customers continuously elevate their expectations with each customer-experience innovation in the marketplace.
Traditional brick-and-mortar and pure e-commerce retailers alike find themselves up against tenaciously innovative competitors that are increasingly finding ways to engage and delight the customer in more comprehensive and differentiating ways. Behind this pervasive disruption is the unsung superhero, supply chain, which is called upon to enable what a mere decade ago would have been wishful fantasy.
With just 8 percent of supply chain executives1 surveyed believing that their organizations are structured correctly to operate in this new environment, retailers and consumer products companies alike are now making significant investments to transform their supply chains. While urgent, the transformations need to be thought through and implemented with an enterprise-wide road map, something that nearly half of executives currently don’t have when embarking on the omnichannel journey, according to a recent survey of senior supply chain executives.2
Retail Digital Supply Chains: Facing an omnichannel customer-driven landscape
Can you profitably deliver shopping experiences customers expect?
Providing a good retailer experience for a shopper in search of the right pair of shoes for a wedding shouldn’t be a Herculean task. But with the customer expecting a broad and seamless experience, the range of technology-based capabilities that a retailer needs to employ can be overwhelming.
Customers today want whatever goods they need, whenever and wherever it suits them. For a retailer—or even a consumer products company—seeking to connect directly with the end consumer has become essential. These omnichannel capabilities must enable seamless cross-channel shopping with multiple delivery options, a personalized touch, assurance of stock levels and delivery times, availability to suggest appropriate alternatives, communications in real time, and hassle-free returns.
Can you deliver? The answer is probably, “Not yet.” According to the Deloitte supply chain executive survey, only 58 percent of shoppers are “satisfied” with their shopping experience and just one-third are “very satisfied.” Online shoppers say they’re much happier (70 percent) than in-store shoppers (55 percent).3 The biggest drivers of customer satisfaction online among respondents are total price, transactional ease, assortment breadth, delivery modality, and delivery assurance.
The impact of customer-driven supply chain
There are significant supply chain implications for retailers that seek to deliver a whatever-whenever-wherever experience.
- Increased fulfillment costs
- Complex inventory challenges
- Changing demand patterns
- Increasing returns volume
- Constrained systems
- Constrained physical network
Linear supply chains that sequentially hand off information aren’t designed to solve the complex supply chain challenges of a customer-centric world that changes dynamically in real time.
Under the surface: Empowering omnichannel with digitally enabled supply networks
While it’s straightforward to identify best-in-class customer-driven capabilities in the retail space, it can be perplexing to determine all that’s required behind the scenes to make them work. Many brick-and-mortar retailers have built out their e-commerce platforms by making modifications on top of legacy system platforms—developed more than a decade earlier—to manage a supply chain moving truckloads of pallets from point to point. This patchwork approach enabled many brick-and-mortar retailers to open e-commerce functionality.
The transformation to an effective omnichannel market offering begins with the recognition that omnichannel supply chain leaders are moving away from the linear logic of traditional supply chain thinking. Computing power has continued to increase exponentially, even as costs for data storage and bandwidth have declined commensurately. This has led to a digital industrial revolution, where highly connected supply networks can be dynamically planned, tracked, directed, expedited, merged, modified, optimized, and taught—all the way from upstream commodities to retail shelf placement.
These major, sustained advances in technology have helped propel increasingly demanding customer expectations to get whatever customers want—where and when, largely without sacrificing quality and price. To fulfill these heightened levels of expectation, a new supply chain model is called for, one built around a digital core of information that enables a dynamic capture and flow of data, full network visibility, real-time analytics, and machine learning capabilities that improve and automate decision-making. We call this next generation of supply chain strategy the DSN.
From the traditional linear supply chain to the interconnected, always-on digital supply network (DSN)
Digital supply networks are “always on.” They’re dynamic and leverage Internet of Things (IoT) sensors, applications, and artificial intelligence to make real-time decisions, such as assessing the impact on fresh produce expiration from temperature variations or dwell time in transit to the store. DSNs are interconnected with end-to-end visibility, centrally linking information and decisions from other nodes and flows in the network, suppliers, partners, and customers.
Rather than supply chain decisions being made in a linear way, a DSN recognizes that every touchpoint, flow, and hold of the network possesses information that can influence a decision taken just about anywhere in the supply network. An out-of-stock in St. Louis may trigger an immediate rerouting in Chicago. Real-time information and decision-making enables more goods to be flowed rather than being held as staple stock.
With a DSN, the inflexible, sequential nature of traditional retail supply chains is replaced by a multidimensional model that can orchestrate inventory and fulfillment decisions dynamically across the entire network to intelligently optimize service quality and cost. The combination of humans, machines, data-driven analytics, predictive insights, and proactive action creates a closed loop of learning.
Building a DSN to enable the customer-driven shopping experience: Getting started
Leveraging its supply chain expertise, Deloitte recently conducted executive interviews, analyzed vendor product road maps, identified a total of 158 supply chain core capabilities, and evaluated each against the relevance for enabling today’s customer-centric supply chain. Of those 158 capabilities, 10 were singled out as most essential to enabling today’s customer-centric supply chain.4 Perhaps most noteworthy is that all 10 of these capabilities require new digital capabilities to fully enable them.
Foundational capabilities are generally regarded as being the most fundamental of the top 10 key supply chain capabilities. Not only can they provide substantial operational benefit to the retailer, but they also provide the grounding for more advanced capabilities. In some instances, foundational capabilities may drive decisions around which core technology architecture and systems to select for key supply chain applications, such as warehouse management or inventory and order management. Every retailer is unique and has different objectives, strengths, and challenges. The sequence below is intended to serve as a general guide.
- End-to-end analytics
- Network inventory visibility
- Integrated demand forecast
- Supplier and carrier connectivity
Advanced capabilities are generally regarded as being more complex or are dependent on foundational capabilities. While the three advanced capabilities below represent three of the most important retail supply chain capabilities to have, they’re by no means exhaustive.
- Available to promise/on-shelf availability
- Order fulfillment optimization
- Continuous-flow order processing
Additional key capabilities: Rounding out the 10 most important supply chain capabilities in a customer-driven retail world are three capabilities that build upon the seven foundational and advanced capabilities:
- Last mile delivery optimization
- Dynamic workforce management
- Cross-channel returns management
While these are the top 10 capabilities generally regarded as most important, they by no means represent the only ones that a given retailer should target or focus on. However, they do provide focus to a priority starting point—one enabled by a digital supply network.
Building a DSN to enable the customer-driven shopping experience: Getting started
The first step in developing a digitally enabled supply chain that fulfills the customer-driven shopping experience is to understand the strategic objectives and longer-term direction of the business. There’s no one-size-fits-all solution, and the future-state supply chain design should be defined by the uniqueness of the business it’s serving.
Only after understanding the strategic business requirements of tomorrow can the future state DSN be envisioned. This vision should include design of the fulfillment network to execute the business strategy, identification of the capabilities required, data needs, and scenario analyses that “pressure test” assumptions and future variability.
The capabilities needed to achieve the future-state customer-centric vision can be daunting, but organizations should take the time to develop a robust road map that starts from a strong digital core with end-to-end transparency. From there, foundational capabilities—fundamental to the business—can be sown, followed by more advanced capabilities that become differentiating.
If not prepared to make an enterprise-wide transformation, consider ways to incorporate key attributes of the DSN that move the organization closer toward the customer-driven supply chain. Establish order to the digital aspects of the supply chain, create a single source of truth, expand it end to end, provide enterprise visibility, make it dynamic, plug in capabilities—and begin down the road to a best-in-class-world-enabled digital supply network.
1 Gerald C. Kane, Doug Palmer, Anh Nguyen Phillips, David Kiron, and Natasha Buckley, “Achieving digital maturity: Adapting your company to a changing world,” MIT Sloan Review and Deloitte, July 13
2 SCM World, World Survey of Global Supply Chain Officers, 2017.
3 Deloitte Consulting LLP research
4 The Nielsen Company, “e-Commerce: Evolution or Revolution in the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods World?,” August 2014, https://www.nielsen.com/us/en/insights/reports/2014/e-commerce-evolution-or-revolution-in-the-fast-moving-consumer-goods-world.html.