PA Department of Revenue bulletin: Federal 100 percent expensing deduction disallowed has been saved
PA Department of Revenue bulletin: Federal 100 percent expensing deduction disallowed
Multistate Tax alert | January 2, 2018
This tax alert summarizes Bulletin 2017-02, discusses background of the CNIT treatment of so-called “bonus depreciation” deductions pursuant to IRC §168(k) and provides taxpayer considerations.
- Pennsylvania CNIT treatment of bonus depreciation
- Taxpayer considerations
- Multistate Tax alert archive
Pursuant to the federal tax reform legislation enacted on December, 22, 2017, Internal Revenue Code (IRC) §168(k) is amended to provide 100 percent expensing for certain business assets placed in service after September 27, 2017, and before January 1, 2023.1 On this same day, the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue (Department) issued Corporation Tax Bulletin 2017-02 (Bulletin 2017-02) which explains the Pennsylvania Corporate Net Income Tax (CNIT) treatment of the 100 percent depreciation claimed as a deduction for federal income tax purposes.2 According to Bulletin 2017-02, Pennsylvania law requires the federal 100 percent deduction to be added back to taxable income for CNIT purposes and provides no additional mechanism for cost recovery until the qualified property is sold or otherwise disposed of. This appears to be a reversal of the Department’s prior policy, which had allowed full recovery of 100 percent depreciation for CNIT purposes in the same year the deduction was claimed for federal income tax purposes.3
Pennsylvania CNIT treatment of bonus depreciation
Pennsylvania law generally provides that any deduction for depreciation of qualified property pursuant to IRC §168(k) must be added back to Pennsylvania taxable income for CNIT purposes.4 To recover the amount added back, Pennsylvania law provides for an additional deduction equal to 3/7ths of the remaining federal depreciation deduction (the 3/7ths formula) if a deduction for depreciation was included in taxable income for CNIT purposes. The law also provides for recovery of any remainder upon sale or other disposition of the property.5
Historically, when the federal law allowed a 30 percent bonus depreciation deduction and a 70 percent regular depreciation deduction, the 3/7ths formula resulted in full recovery of the cost of the qualified property over its regular depreciable life.6 When the federal bonus allowance was subsequently increased to 50 percent, with the remaining 50 percent subject to regular depreciation, the 3/7ths formula no longer recovered the entire cost prior to disposition of the property; however, the Department allowed for recovery of the remainder in the final year of federal depreciation.7 Likewise, when the federal bonus allowance temporarily increased to 100 percent during parts of 2010 and 2011, the Department, pursuant to Corporation Tax Bulletin 2011-01, allowed full recovery in the same year as the federal deduction.8
Bulletin 2017-02 appears to reverse the Department’s prior policy which had allowed for full recovery of 100 percent expensing deductions and instead applies a narrow interpretation of the CNIT statutory addback and recovery provisions. According to Bulletin 2017-02, while Pennsylvania still requires an addback of the full federal bonus deduction, no additional deduction is allowed for CNIT purposes because there is no corresponding federal deduction for regular depreciation for such property.9
Further, applying the 3/7ths formula would result in an additional CNIT deduction of zero because there is no remaining federal depreciation amount after the 100 percent deduction.10 Thus, the Department concludes that no cost recovery will be permitted for CNIT purposes until the property is sold or otherwise disposed of.11
The Department’s revised bonus depreciation policy announced in Bulletin 2017-02 creates the potential for Pennsylvania CNIT income to be significantly higher than federal taxable income for periods during which the federal 100 percent expensing deduction is claimed. As a result of the new policy, effective for property placed in service after September 27, 2017, taxpayers will need to track a different Pennsylvania basis in such property in order to properly recover the addback in a future year when such property is sold or otherwise disposed of.12 Taxpayers are also advised to closely monitor other states’ responses to the new federal 100 percent expensing provisions.
If you have questions regarding Bulletin 2017-02 or other Pennsylvania tax matters, please contact any of the following Deloitte Tax professionals:
Todd Hyman, partner, Deloitte Tax LLP, Philadelphia, +1 215 299 4539
Ed Kenawell, principal, Deloitte Tax LLP, Pittsburgh, +1 412 338 7884
Kenn Stoops, managing director, Deloitte Tax LLP, Philadelphia, +1 215 299 5225
Steven Thompson, managing director, Deloitte Tax LLP, Philadelphia, +1 215 246 2463
Stacy Ip-Mo, senior manager, Deloitte Tax LLP, Philadelphia, +1 215 246 2374
Bob Kovach, senior manager, Deloitte Tax LLP, Pittsburgh, +1 412 338 7925
Multistate Tax alert archive
The Multistate Tax alert archive includes external tax alerts issued by Deloitte Tax LLP's Multistate Tax practice during the last three years. These external alerts highlight selected developments involving state tax legislative, judicial, and administrative matters. The alerts provide a brief summary of specific multistate developments relevant to taxpayers, tax professionals, and other interested persons.
View the list of archived Multistate Tax alerts.
1 H.R. 1, Sec. 13201. The Act also provides for declining expensing deductions for property placed in service after December 31, 2022.
2 Pennsylvania Department of Revenue, Corporation Tax Bulletin 2017-02 (Dec. 22, 2017), available here. Bulletin 2017-02 is limited in scope to a discussion of “Disallowance and Recovery of 100 Percent Depreciation Under IRC 168(k)” and does not address the recovery of declining deductions after then 100 percent expensing period expires.
4 72 P.S. § 7401(3)1.(q), a/k/a Tax Reform Code (TRC) § 401(3)1.(q).
5 72 P.S. § 7401(3)1.(r) / TRC § 401(3)1.(r).
6 Under the 30 percent bonus model, the formula multiplies the remaining 70 percent federal non-bonus depreciation by 3/7, resulting in an additional 30 percent deduction (70 percent / 3 x 7 = 30 percent) over the regular depreciable life, thereby restoring the disallowed 30 percent bonus deduction.
7 Corporation Tax Bulletin 2011-01.
9 Corporation Tax Bulletin 2017-02.
11 Id. Note that Bulletin 2017-02 makes no distinction between property located inside or outside Pennsylvania.
12 The change in policy will not affect deductions allowed under Bulletin 2011-01 for property placed in service prior to the effective date.