Viewing offline content

Limited functionality available

Dismiss
Deloitte Middle East
Annotations
  • Services

    What's New

    • Deloitte175

      Join us for a celebration of 175 years of making an impact that matters.

    • Building the Resilient Organization

      2021 Deloitte Global resilience report

    • 2020 Global Gender Impact Report

      A collection of Butterfly Effect stories highlighting how our Deloitte professionals are positively impacting the lives of women and girls around the world

    • Audit & Assurance

      • Assurance
    • Consulting

      • Strategy, Analytics and M&A
      • Customer and Marketing
      • Business Operations
      • Human Capital
      • Enterprise Technology & Performance
    • Financial Advisory

      • Mergers & Acquisitions
      • Forensic
      • Real Estate
      • Turnaround & Restructuring
    • Risk Advisory

      • Strategic & Reputation Risk
      • Regulatory Risk
      • Financial Risk
      • Operational Risk
      • Cyber Risk
    • Tax

      • Global Business Tax Services
      • Indirect Tax
      • Global Employer Services
    • Deloitte Private

      • Family Enterprise
    • Legal

    • Sustainability

  • Industries

    What's New

    • Deloitte perspectives

      Leadership perspectives from across the globe.

    • Deloitte Insights App

      Our thought leadership and Dow Jones news, now at your fingertips

    • Future of Mobility

      Learn how this new reality is coming together and what it will mean for you and your industry.

    • Consumer

      • Automotive
      • Consumer Products
      • Retail, Wholesale & Distribution
      • Transportation, Hospitality & Services
    • Energy, Resources & Industrials

      • Industrial Products & Construction
      • Mining & Metals
      • Oil, Gas & Chemicals
      • Power, Utilities & Renewables
    • Financial Services

      • Banking & Capital Markets
      • Insurance
      • Investment Management
      • Real Estate
    • Government & Public Services

      • Civil Government
      • Defense, Security & Justice
      • Health & Social Care
      • Transport
    • Life Sciences & Health Care

      • Health Care
      • Life Sciences
    • MENA Sovereign Wealth Funds

    • Technology, Media & Telecommunications

      • Technology
      • Telecommunications, Media & Entertainment
  • Insights

    Deloitte Insights

    What's New

    • Deloitte Insights Magazine

      Explore the latest issue now

    • Deloitte Insights app

      Go straight to smart with daily updates on your mobile device

    • Weekly economic update

      See what's happening this week and the impact on your business

    • Strategy

      • Business Strategy & Growth
      • Digital Transformation
      • Governance & Board
      • Innovation
      • Marketing & Sales
      • Private Enterprise
    • Economy & Society

      • Economy
      • Environmental, Social, & Governance
      • Health Equity
      • Trust
      • Mobility
    • Organization

      • Operations
      • Finance & Tax
      • Risk & Regulation
      • Supply Chain
      • Smart Manufacturing
    • People

      • Leadership
      • Talent & Work
      • Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
    • Technology

      • Data & Analytics
      • Emerging Technologies
      • Technology Management
    • Industries

      • Consumer
      • Energy, Resources, & Industrials
      • Financial Services
      • Government & Public Services
      • Life Sciences & Health Care
      • Technology, Media, & Telecommunications
    • Spotlight

      • Deloitte Insights Magazine
      • Press Room Podcasts
      • Weekly Economic Update
      • COVID-19
      • Resilience
  • Careers

    What's New

    • Millennial Survey 2022

      Gen Zs and millennials are striving for balance and advocating for change.

    • Candidate Profile

      After applying for a job in this country, you can access/update your candidate profile at any time.

    • Job Search

    • Students

    • Experienced Hires

    • Executives

    • Life at Deloitte

    • Alumni

    • Diversity and Inclusion

  • XE-EN Location: XE-English  
  • Contact us
  • XE-EN Location: XE-English  
  • Contact us
    • Dashboard
    • Saved items
    • Content feed
    • Profile/Interests
    • Account settings

Welcome back

Still not a member? Join My Deloitte

How cocreation is helping accelerate product and service innovation

by Anne Kwan, Maximilian Schroeck, Jon Kawamura
  • Save for later
  • Download
  • Share
    • Share on Facebook
    • Share on Twitter
    • Share on Linkedin
    • Share by email
Deloitte Insights
  • Strategy
    Strategy
    Strategy
    • Business Strategy & Growth
    • Digital Transformation
    • Governance & Board
    • Innovation
    • Marketing & Sales
    • Private Enterprise
  • Economy & Society
    Economy & Society
    Economy & Society
    • Economy
    • Environmental, Social, & Governance
    • Health Equity
    • Trust
    • Mobility
  • Organization
    Organization
    Organization
    • Operations
    • Finance & Tax
    • Risk & Regulation
    • Supply Chain
    • Smart Manufacturing
  • People
    People
    People
    • Leadership
    • Talent & Work
    • Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
  • Technology
    Technology
    Technology
    • Data & Analytics
    • Emerging Technologies
    • Technology Management
  • Industries
    Industries
    Industries
    • Consumer
    • Energy, Resources, & Industrials
    • Financial Services
    • Government & Public Services
    • Life Sciences & Health Care
    • Tech, Media, & Telecom
  • Spotlight
    Spotlight
    Spotlight
    • Deloitte Insights Magazine
    • Press Room Podcasts
    • Weekly Economic Update
    • COVID-19
    • Resilience
    • XE-EN Location: XE-English  
    • Contact us
      • Dashboard
      • Saved items
      • Content feed
      • Profile/Interests
      • Account settings
    10 minute read 20 April 2020

    How cocreation is helping accelerate product and service innovation In an Industry 4.0 environment, many companies are augmenting their approaches to the development of new offerings

    10 minute read 20 April 2020
    • Anne Kwan United States
    • Maximilian Schroeck United States
    • Jon Kawamura United States
    • Anne Kwan United States
    • Maximilian Schroeck United States
    • Jon Kawamura United States
    • See more See more See less
      • Anne Kwan United States
      • Maximilian Schroeck United States
      • Jon Kawamura United States
    • Save for later
    • Download
    • Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on Linkedin
      • Share by email
    • Introduction
    • Cocreation: Innovating beyond traditional boundaries
    • Co-creation vs. other innovation pathways
    • With whom to co-create?
    • How to co-create?
    • If you do only five things
    • Closing thoughts

    ​Rapid innovation cycles are critical to winning in the Industry 4.0 era. This article, the 10th in a series on digital industrial transformation, explores how cocreation can help companies accelerate and de-risk innovation.

    Introduction

    Traditionally, R&D drives companies’ product innovation and technological advancements. But changing customer expectations and the ubiquity of startup funding, culture, and processes—promoting rapid, agile, and use case–focused innovation—are pressuring leaders to shift their approach to the development of new offerings. This is now truer for B2B companies than ever before, as offering simplicity and strong customer experiences in consumer products have permeated B2B buying processes, customer support, and product updates.

    Learn more

    Explore the Digital industrial transformation collection

    Learn more about Deloitte's services

    Go straight to smart. Download the Deloitte Insights app

    The impact has begun to reverberate not only across the technology and industrial sectors but across the economy, broadly. For example, a major European bank, known for its hierarchical and policy-driven offer development, restructured its product innovation-related functions (including IT development, product management, and marketing) into small agile “squads,” resulting in faster time to market, greater customer satisfaction, and higher employee engagement.1

    Many technology buyers are increasingly expecting quicker and easier integration of new products or solutions with their enterprise systems and applications in order to realize a faster return on their investments. This is especially important as technology budgets often extend outside IT managers to line managers, including operational technology groups. More and more, these buyers expect value through integrated solutions.

    But developing and delivering these integrated solutions is often challenging for a single company to address independently, cost-efficiently, and effectively. (See figure 1 for examples of challenges organizations typically face when trying to innovate.) While organizations should continue to invest in robust internal R&D capabilities, today’s changing business environment indicates that companies expand their sources of innovation.

    Typical innovation challenges

    As such, companies have begun to look beyond their four walls to break free of organizational constraints and stay ahead of the curve. In this article, we discuss how collaborative innovation compares to other product development and innovation approaches, the types of innovation partners that might be involved, leading practices, and some success stories from across the marketplace.

    “Consider this article the playbook—or a primer—that complements this series’ seventh installment, which addresses how to extract greater efficiency from internal product development.”2

    Cocreation: Innovating beyond traditional boundaries

    In today’s market, ever fewer organizations can rely exclusively on an internal R&D process to generate innovation. A model of cooperative innovation—an ecosystem—is increasingly critical to drive value for all parties involved. We see this as cocreation—strategic partners actively collaborating to create and deliver customer-centric products and services (offers) that capture greater value, more rapidly and at lower risk than traditional product-development approaches. Figure 2 discusses the benefits of cocreation in greater detail.

    A variety of companies are engaging in cocreation—a recent report found that most European organizations have already launched at least one cocreation pilot formally or rolled out cocreation, with 57 percent noting that it transformed their company’s approach to innovation.3

    Figure 2. Benefits of co-creation

    Case study: IBM and CISCO

    Cocreation vs. other innovation pathways

    As cycle times of technological innovations shrink,6 companies have begun to explore new ways to innovate, including strategic partnerships, research labs, and joint innovation centers. Today, companies often have several levers they can pull to support product development. (See figure 3 for a comparison across common pathways to innovation.) Among these, cocreation provides a unique blend of control, cost, and time to impact.

    “As cycle times of technological innovations shrink, companies have begun to explore new ways to innovate, including strategic partnerships, research labs, and joint innovation centers.”

    Typical innovation challenges by approach

    With whom to cocreate?

    Organizations that cocreate effectively can engage a broad set of stakeholders to support their innovation needs, including customers, suppliers, competitors, academic institutions, nonprofits, and government agencies. Figure 4 highlights specific marketplace partnerships and the value they have delivered for participants.7

    Types of co-creation partners, with examples

    Given the variety of partners with which an organization can cocreate, it is important to select the right type of partner (and the partner itself) by determining internal capability gaps, aligning on partnership goals, and defining a mutual value proposition. As with all partnerships, it is critical that both organizations bring value to the table, so leaders should ask themselves: “What do we have that partners want—or can benefit from?” Most companies assume that their IP makes them valuable to prospective partners; this may be true, but equally important are a healthy risk appetite, a track record of acting collaboratively and with agility, and access to capital, talent, and markets. Finally, cocreators should align on their approach to privacy and data security; these areas are becoming increasingly critical as competitive differentiators given consumer and regulatory scrutiny, so alignment on how data is collected, stored, and monetized is paramount.

    “My favorite form of cocreation is when you find a collaborator in someone that you least expected, maybe even a former competitor that actually complements me more than we compete. The question then remains: How do we make this work going forward?”

    —Robert Schmid, chief futurist, Deloitte Consulting LLP

    Case study: Apple and Mastercard

    How to cocreate?

    While the nature of the solution and choice of partners are critical, we often find the operating and engagement model to be the biggest roadblock in achieving cocreation goals. Operationalizing cocreation requires taking three critical steps. The approach is not dissimilar from developing products internally, discussed in our article on digital product management.11

    Why: Strategic objectives

    The first step is to align on objectives and priorities of the cocreation initiative. Specifically, leaders should:

    • Determine the scope—product, market, customer, investment profile, duration
    • Define success criteria—revenue, market share, product launches, recognition
    • Identify cocreation timelines
    • Align on investments and outcomes that will be shared—equally, by market, by time

    For example, TM Forum’s Catalyst platform connects communication service providers with other firms to jointly develop proof of concepts to address common challenges in the telecom ecosystem across emerging areas, such as 5G, AI, and the IoT.12

    Who: Capabilities and roles

    Organizations engaging in cocreation usually do so because of the complementary capabilities that they bring to the table (figure 5 showcases the key capabilities). Therefore, companies should determine:

    • Capabilities required to deliver on the strategic objectives—product, go-to-market, support, services
    • How each capability will be delivered—remotely, by a third party, together, as a service
    • The role each partner would play in delivering the capabilities—resources, investment, technology, suppliers and distributors

    Key product capabilities required

    Like the product capabilities listed above, companies typically go beyond product development to align roles across marketing, sales, servicing, and support capabilities. Indeed, examples of complementary capabilities are widespread across technology firms and automobile original equipment manufacturers (OEMs), where the former provides semiconductor and/or software development capability required for cutting-edge applications such as self-driving cars, while the latter offers manufacturing expertise to build complex hardware at scale with high reliability and durability.

    How: Operating model

    Another critical step is to determine the operating model for cocreating teams. While there are multiple options available to structure teams, the optimal choice will depend on capabilities selected, their maturity, partner roles, and the nature of the working relationship (figure 6).

    Teaming options

    Not every partnership is successful, of course. Some cocreators discover that they have differing visions well into their partnership; other partnerships fail because initial product launches fall short of expectations. Some partnerships lose their spark gradually as the initial excitement fades. We see value, then, in driving accountability—at the executive level—for managing a network of cocreation partnerships. Also, extending the principles of agile product development to partnership building—employing a “learn fast” method—makes for better allocation of scarce resources to the most lucrative partnerships.

    If you do only five things

    While cocreation can be a force multiplier for innovating in an Industry 4.0 environment, the probability of success depends on the right environment. Our experiences as both advisers and cocreators have unearthed five elements that are accretive to cocreation pursuits:

    Structure of the entity and allocation of IP ownership. While informal collaboration and even sharing of resources might work, it is often beneficial to set up an equity alliance or joint venture. This is especially useful in situations where partners are new to working with one another, or in multipartner cocreation. Additionally, it helps to clarify how ownership rights for new IP from the partnership will be allocated. However, the complexity and management overhead typically follow a stated, long-term commitment to collaboration. We will explore this in greater depth in another article in this series.

    Go-to-market and rights to monetize. It is critical to clarify how each partner will reap financial benefits from cocreation, including the appropriate monetization model (revenue share, license fees, commissions, royalties, etc.) for IP and data generated from launching the innovation, as well as ownership of go-to-market efforts. When multiple participants are involved in taking innovations to market, collaborators should proactively reduce the probability of conflict by identifying the customer segments that each partner will target—for example, by size, geography, or industry.

    Governance. Maintaining momentum throughout the cocreation requires clear stage gates or key milestones to review progress to ensure teams are not overburdened with frequent or unnecessary reporting activities. As such, it is crucial that companies define early what happens at these milestones—for example, expectations of progress made, decision-makers, scope of decision-making, and processes for escalating unresolved issues. Finally, agreement on conditions, rights, and outcomes related to termination of the partnership can de-risk transitions in unfavorable situations.

    Culture and organization. Cocreation involves a shift in thinking from the organization as the sole driver of innovation to collaboration with a network of partners within and outside the industry. This requires change management to embrace partners’ cultural changes along with their unique talent models, processes, and technologies. For example, it might be helpful to change frequency and type of progress reporting in partnering with startups or academic institutions that may be unused to a corporate setup.

    Enabling infrastructure. Interorganization collaboration requires enabling technologies, tools, and processes that protect each party’s independent interests. For example, collaboration platforms that enable real-time communication, coordination, and content sharing—such as Slack, Teams, and Jira—can significantly ease teaming across organizations. Additionally, setting up “clean rooms”—digital storage of sensitive business assets—with defined and restricted access across participating organizations can support data sharing without leakage of sensitive information.

    “While cocreation can be a force multiplier for innovating in an Industry 4.0 environment, the probability of success depends on the right environment.”

    Case study: Intel and SAP

    Closing thoughts

    Across sectors, pioneering companies have profited by expanding innovation outside their organizational boundaries.17 The most successful innovators are now leveraging an ecosystem strategy to align their product portfolio with technology shifts, market trends, and evolving customer needs. A cocreation strategy and operating model that align with overall corporate strategy and innovation objectives can position organizations for success in the digital economy.

    Indeed, cocreators and collaborators come from a variety of places, and enterprises that proactively seek out new partnerships and dynamically evaluate existing ones are likely to reap the greatest benefits. So with whom will you cocreate next—and where will you find your cocreator?

    Acknowledgments

    The authors would like to thank Rohan Gupta and Luv Parakh of Deloitte Consulting LLP for their research and dedication to bringing this article to life. The authors would like to recognize Divya Viswanathan, Mayukh Bhadra Chowdhury, and Rashmi Ravindran Colanukuduru of Deloitte Consulting LLP for their contributions to the Digital Transformation and Co-creation practices.

    Cover image by: Sonya Vasilief

    Endnotes
      1. Dominic Barton, Dennis Carey, and Ram Charan, “One bank’s agile team experiment,” Harvard Business Review, March–April 2018. View in article

      2. Jon Kawamura, Maximilian Schroeck, and Anne Kwan, Digital product management: A structured approach to product innovation and governance, Deloitte Insights, October 18, 2019. View in article

      3. Hitachi, Co-creating the future, accessed March 18, 2020. View in article

      4. Chris O’Connor, “IBM and Cisco: Understanding critical data on the network edge,” IBM Internet of Things blog, June 28, 2017. View in article

      5. Mike Flannagan, “Announcing a first of a kind technology combining IBM’s Watson IoT Cognitive Computing and Cisco’s Edge Analytics,” Cisco Blogs, June 2, 2016. View in article

      6. Barry Ritholtz, “The world is about to undergo even faster change,” IndustryWeek, July 10, 2017. View in article

      7. Sources clockwise from top of figure: Oriol Iglesias, “Why your company should embrace co-creation,” Forbes, September 24, 2018; Aaron Mehta, “Experiment over: Pentagon’s tech hub gets a vote of confidence,” Defense News, August 9, 2018; Laura Cox, “Business & academia—5 exciting partnerships,” Disruption Hub, February 22, 2017; Jaguar Land Rover, “Jaguar Land Rover & BMW Group announce collaboration for next generation electrification technology,” June 5, 2019; Hitachi, “Co-creating the future.” View in article

      8. Apple Pay and Apple Card are trademarks of Apple Inc., registered in the United States and other countries. This article is an independent publication and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Apple Inc. View in article

      9. PaymentsJournal, “Mastercard and Apple taking on a digital first approach to payments,” April 3, 2019. View in article

      10. Alex Rolfe, “Apple Pay adoption continues to rise as 43% of base now registered,” Payments Cards & Mobile, February 25, 2019; John Detrixhe, “ Apple Pay is on pace to account for 10% of all global card transactions,” Quartz, February 11, 2020. View in article

      11. Kawamura, Schroeck, and Kwan, Digital product management. View in article

      12. TM Forum, “What is a catalyst?,” accessed February 26, 2020. View in article

      13. SAP, “SAP corporate fact sheet,” accessed March 18, 2020. View in article

      14. Dylan Martin, “Intel to supercharge SAP applications in new multi-year partnership,” CRN, July 18, 2019. View in article

      15. Dylan Martin, “Jason Kimrey: Intel’s data-centric platform strategy is a winning hand for partners,” CRN, July 8, 2019. View in article

      16. IT Peer Network, “Intel and SAP go big—here’s what you need to know,” Intel, July 19, 2019. View in article

      17. Ulrich Lichtenthaler, Martin Hoegl, and Miriam Muethel, “Is your company ready for open innovation?,” MIT Sloan Management Review, September 21, 2011. View in article

    Show moreShow less

    Topics in this article

    Digital Transformation , Industry 4.0 , Innovation , Technology , Technology Industry , Strategy

    ​Deloitte Consulting

    ​Deloitte Consulting LLP’s Digital Transformation practice has advised clients in the technology sector (e.g., hardware, software, semiconductors), as well as those in the industrial sector (e.g., manufacturing, construction, and energy) enter and compete in new markets. Our work includes defining customer-first strategies, building new business and operating models, and launching the critical capabilities required to swiftly drive scale—all to achieve optimal results from limited resource pools.

    Learn more
    Get in touch
    Contact
    • Anne Kwan
    • Managing director
    • Deloitte Consulting LLP
    • annkwan@deloitte.com
    • +1 415 783 6379

    Download Subscribe

    Related content

    img Trending

    Ecosystem-driven portfolio strategy

    Article 2 years ago
    img Trending

    Radically transforming your support models

    Article 2 years ago
    img Trending

    Digital product management

    Article 2 years ago
    img Trending

    Scaling up anything as-a-service

    Article 2 years ago

    Explore the Digital transformation collection

    • Customer-centric digital transformation Article2 years ago
    • Architecting an operating model Article2 years ago
    • Digital transformation as a path to growth Article2 years ago
    • Staying focused and on track in Industry 4.0 Article2 years ago
    • Digital industrial transformation Article3 years ago
    • Ethical tech Article2 years ago
    Anne Kwan

    Anne Kwan

    Transformation Strategy & Design Leader

    Anne is a principal with Deloitte Consulting LLP, where she serves as the leader of Deloitte’s Transformation Strategy & Design services. In this role, she oversees a community of architects, who help executives navigate "big T" transformation programs, which involve fundamental changes to their business model portfolio and/or enterprise model design. Her team helps executives articulate their transformation ambition, quantify those aspirations and architect a multi-sprint execution roadmap. Anne practices within the Technology, Media, and Telecommunication (TMT) industry. She helps her clients launch new, emerging businesses and optimize their core businesses for competitive advantage. Anne specializes in business model innovation, product strategy, capability architecture and enterprise model design. With a background in software product development, she brings 18+ years of technology industry and management consulting experience; leading strategic programs and mission critical initiatives. Her experience spans both organic and inorganic growth via mergers and acquisitions.

    • annkwan@deloitte.com
    • +1 415 783 6379
    Maximilian Schroeck

    Maximilian Schroeck

    Principal | Deloitte Consulting LLP

    Maximilian Schroek is a principal with Deloitte’s Global Clients & Industries and US TMT leadership teams and serves as Deloitte’s Global Chief Commercial Officer (CCO), Salesforce Alliance. He also is the senior advisory partner for multiple global client relationships as well as for Deloitte’s Strategic Growth Transformation practice. Previously, he served as Deloitte’s Global Technology Sector Consulting leader. He has more than 25 years of experience in leading global organizations in consulting, private equity, corporate development, and new business development and specializes in digital transformation, corporate growth and innovation.

    • mschroeck@deloitte.com
    • +1 408 704 4158
    Jon Kawamura

    Jon Kawamura

    Jon Kawamura is a managing director in Deloitte’s Technology Strategy and Architecture practice. He has more than 20 years of experience leading IT and operational projects across multiple industries with a recent focus on serving high-tech clients. Kawamura is based in San Francisco. 

    • jkawamura@deloitte.com

    Share article highlights

    See something interesting? Simply select text and choose how to share it:

    Email a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
    Copy a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
    Copy your highlighted text.

    How cocreation is helping accelerate product and service innovation has been saved

    How cocreation is helping accelerate product and service innovation has been removed

    An Article Titled How cocreation is helping accelerate product and service innovation already exists in Saved items

     
    Forgot password

    To stay logged in, change your functional cookie settings.

    OR

    Social login not available on Microsoft Edge browser at this time.

    Connect Accounts

    Connect your social accounts

    This is the first time you have logged in with a social network.

    You have previously logged in with a different account. To link your accounts, please re-authenticate.

    Log in with an existing social network:

    To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

    OR

    Log in with an existing site account:

    To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

    Forgot password

    Subscribe

    to receive more business insights, analysis, and perspectives from Deloitte Insights
    ✓ Link copied to clipboard
    • Contact us
    • Search Jobs
    • Submit RFP
    Follow Deloitte Insights:
    Global office directory Office locations
    XE-EN Location: XE-English  
    About Deloitte
    • Newsroom
    • Deloitte events
    • Our blog collections
    • Press releases
    • Press contacts
    • Corporate Responsibility & Sustainability
    • Report an ethics complaint
    Services
    • Audit & Assurance
    • Consulting
    • Financial Advisory
    • Risk Advisory
    • Tax
    • Deloitte Private
    • Legal
    • Sustainability
    Industries
    • Consumer
    • Energy, Resources & Industrials
    • Financial Services
    • Government & Public Services
    • Life Sciences & Health Care
    • MENA Sovereign Wealth Funds
    • Technology, Media & Telecommunications
    Careers
    • Job Search
    • Students
    • Experienced Hires
    • Executives
    • Life at Deloitte
    • Alumni
    • Diversity and Inclusion
    • About Deloitte
    • About Deloitte in the Middle East
    • Privacy
    • Terms of use
    • Cookies
    • Avature Privacy

    © 2022. See Terms of Use for more information.

    Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee (“DTTL”), its network of member firms, and their related entities. DTTL and each of its member firms are legally separate and independent entities. DTTL (also referred to as “Deloitte Global”) does not provide services to clients. Please see About Deloitte to learn more about our global network of member firms.