Geographic trends in manufacturing job creation | Deloitte Insights
United States
  • Services
    What's New
    • Deloitte's 2020 Global Marketing Trends

      Learn more

    • Register for Dbriefs webcasts

    • Listen to our podcasts

      From tech tips to financial risks

    Tax
    • Global Business Tax Services
    • Global Employer Services
    • Multistate Tax
    • Operations Transformation for Tax
    Consulting
    Audit & Assurance
    • Audit Innovation
    • Accounting Standards
    • Accounting Events & Transactions
    Deloitte Private Company Services
    Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Total M&A Solution
    • Post-merger Integration
    • Divestiture & Separation
    Risk & Financial Advisory
    • Assurance & Internal Audit
    • Cyber Risk
    • Financial Risk, Transactions & Restructuring
    • Forensic
    • Regulatory & Operations Risk
    • Risk Intelligence
    Analytics
    Cloud
  • Industries
    What's New
    • Read our latest thinking

      Visit Deloitte Insights

    • Register for Dbriefs webcasts

    • Industry Outlooks

      Key opportunities, trends, and challenges

    Consumer
    • Automotive
    • Consumer Products
    • Retail, Wholesale & Distribution
    • Transportation, Hospitality & Services
    Energy, Resources & Industrials
    • Industrial Products & Construction
    • Mining & Metals
    • Oil, Gas & Chemicals
    • Power & Utilities
    Financial Services
    • Banking & Capital Markets
    • Insurance
    • Investment Management
    • Real Estate
    Government & Public Services
    • Civil Government
    • Defense, Security & Justice
    • Federal Health
    • International Donor Organizations
    • State, Local & Higher Education
    • Transport
    Life Sciences & Health Care
    • Health Care
    • Life Sciences
    Technology, Media & Telecommunications
    • Technology
    • Telecommunications, Media & Entertainment
  • Insights

    Deloitte Insights
    What's New
    • Deloitte Review

      Looking ahead, staying ahead

    • Daily executive briefing

      Timely insights to inform your agenda.

    • Deloitte Insights app

      Get daily updates on your mobile device

    By topic
    • AI & cognitive technologies
    • Analytics
    • Blockchain
    • Digital transformation
    • Diversity & inclusion
    • Economics
    • Human capital
    • Innovation
    • Leadership
    • Private companies
    • Risk management
    • Strategy
    By sector
    • Automotive
    • Consumer products & retail
    • Financial services
    • Government & public services
    • Health care
    • Industrial products
    • Life sciences
    • Oil, gas & chemicals
    • Power & utilities
    • Technology
    • Telecom, media & entertainment
    • Transportation & hospitality
    Spotlight
    • Daily Executive Briefing
    • Deloitte Review
    • Economic weekly update
    • Future of mobility
    • Future of work
    • Industry 4.0
    • Internet of Things
    • Smart cities
  • Careers
    What's New
    • Life at Deloitte Podcast

      A podcast by our professionals who share a sneak peek at life inside Deloitte.

    • Life at Deloitte Blog

      Discover Deloitte and learn more about our people and culture.

    • Candidate Profile

      Have you already applied for a job? You can now update your candidate profile here.

    Careers
    • Our Purpose
    • Audit & Assurance
    • Consulting
    • Risk and Financial Advisory
    • Tax
    • Internal Services
    Students
    • Undergraduate
    • Advanced Degree
    • Professional Development
    • Recruiting Process
    • On Campus
    Experienced Professionals
    • Recruiting Process
    • Executives
    • Industries
    Job Search
    • Student Jobs
    • Experienced Professional Jobs
    • Recruiting Tips
    • Explore Your Fit
    • Labor Condition Applications
    Life at Deloitte
    • Life at Deloitte Blog
    • Meet Our People
    • Inclusion
    • Corporate Citizenship
    • Leadership Development
    • Empowered Well-Being
    • Deloitte University
    Alumni Relations
    • Update Your Information
    • Events
    • Career Development Support
    • Marketplace Jobs Dashboard
    • Alumni Resources
  • US-EN Location: United States-English  
    • Contact us
    • US-EN Location: United States-English  
      • Contact us
        • Dashboard
        • Bookmarks
        • Content feed
        • Subscriptions
        • Profile/Interests
        • Account settings

      Welcome back

      Still not a member? Join My Deloitte

      Geographic trends in manufacturing job creation: Something old, something new

      By Dr. Patricia Buckley
      • Add to my bookmarks
      • Highlight
      • Share
        • Share on Facebook
        • Share on Twitter
        • Share on Linkedin
        • Share by email
      Deloitte Insights
      • By topic
        By topic
        By topic
        • AI & cognitive technologies
        • Analytics
        • Blockchain
        • Digital transformation
        • Diversity & inclusion
        • Economics
        • Human capital
        • Innovation
        • Leadership
        • Private companies
        • Risk management
        • Strategy
      • By sector
        By sector
        By sector
        • Automotive
        • Consumer products & retail
        • Financial services
        • Government & public services
        • Health care
        • Industrial products
        • Life sciences
        • Oil, gas & chemicals
        • Power & utilities
        • Technology
        • Telecom, media & entertainment
        • Transportation & hospitality
      • Spotlight
        Spotlight
        Spotlight
        • Daily Executive Briefing
        • Deloitte Review
        • Economic weekly update
        • Future of mobility
        • Future of work
        • Industry 4.0
        • Internet of Things
        • Smart cities
      • US-EN Location: United States-English  
        • Contact us
          • Dashboard
          • Bookmarks
          • Content feed
          • Subscriptions
          • Profile/Interests
          • Account settings
        25 September 2017

        Geographic trends in manufacturing job creation: Something old, something new Behind the Numbers, September 2017

        25 September 2017
        • Dr. Patricia Buckley
        • Add to my bookmarks
        • Highlight
        • Share
          • Share on Facebook
          • Share on Twitter
          • Share on Linkedin
          • Share by email
        • Subdued recovery in manufacturing jobs
        • Decoding the downward national trend
        • Manufacturing jobs in the United States: A state-level view
        • Taking a global perspective

        US manufacturing employment has reached a milestone—1 million jobs created since it bottomed at the beginning of 2010. While much of the job creation occurred in states with a substantial manufacturing base, some relative newcomers have also done well. But even with some recovery, the role of manufacturing as a job creator continues to decrease.

        Subdued recovery in manufacturing jobs

        Learn More

        Explore the Behind the Numbers collection

        From the official beginning of the recession in December 2007 to the manufacturing employment low point at the beginning of 2010, the United States lost, on a net basis, 2.3 million manufacturing jobs.1 It has taken over seven-and-a-half years for manufacturing employment to regain 1 million of those jobs. Over that same period, employment outside of manufacturing increased by 16.8 million jobs. With such disparate rates of increase, it is clear that manufacturing’s share of total employment continued to drop during the recovery period. However, the decline of manufacturing’s relative share was not uniform across the states—some states beat the national trend and more than recovered their state’s manufacturing employment share post 2010 (including some states that had not been manufacturing powerhouses prior to the downturn). But in no state has the proportion of manufacturing jobs reached its prerecession level. Indeed, even in states that had stronger manufacturing employment recoveries, the general trend remains downward. This diversification of job creation away from manufacturing is a trend not unique to the United States. Other advanced countries, along with the larger developing countries, are experiencing the same trend.

        Decoding the downward national trend

        Between 1985 and 2000, US manufacturing employment held relatively steady at just under 17.5 million jobs, after which it began to drop precipitously. By 2006, manufacturing employment had slipped below 14 million and by 2010, it was down to just 11.5 million. Although it has recovered somewhat, currently standing at 12.5 million, the loss of these jobs is even more striking when considered in the context of a growing economy that currently supports 146.6 million jobs in total, well above its prerecession peak. Figure 1 shows this decline in manufacturing employment share since 2000 when manufacturing jobs comprised 13 percent of total employment. During the latest recession, manufacturing jobs disappeared faster than nonmanufacturing jobs, forcing the relative share down to just 9 percent and over the past year, it has been stable at 8.5 percent.

        US manufacturing employment as a percentage of total employment, 2000 to 2017

        Manufacturing jobs in the United States: A state-level view

        On a percentage basis, the 1 million rebound in manufacturing jobs is an 8.4 percent gain over the level of manufacturing employment in January 2010. So where have those jobs been created? Well, not only in the usual places where manufacturing has always been a major employer.

        Figure 2 illustrates the unevenness of the manufacturing recovery. While some states continued to lose jobs post 2010 or experienced only a slight recovery, others saw a much stronger bounce. Michigan, in particular, experienced a very strong recovery, with manufacturing employment growing by 33.3 percent or 151,000 jobs between January 2010 and July 2017.2 Although this gain has boosted the proportion of manufacturing jobs in Michigan from 11.8 percent in 2006 to 13.8 percent currently, Michigan, just as every other state, has a lower proportion of manufacturing jobs than it did prior to the recession, when 15.0 percent of the state’s employment was accounted for by the manufacturing sector. Seven other states also showed percentage gains in manufacturing employment of more than twice the national average—Idaho (25.7 percent), Kentucky (21.9 percent), South Carolina (20.8 percent), Indiana (20.3 percent), Florida (19.3 percent), Oregon (18.9 percent), and Nevada (18.3 percent).

        Percentage change in manufacturing employment between January 2010 and July 2017

        While many of the states that experienced exceedingly strong manufacturing employment gains post 2010 were states that still had a substantial manufacturing employment base in 2010, such as Indiana (where manufacturing was 15.8 percent of total employment), Kentucky (11.9 percent), Michigan (11.8 percent), South Carolina (11.5 percent), and Oregon (10.2 percent), others, such as Idaho (8.9 percent), Florida (4.3 percent), and Nevada (3.4 percent), had manufacturing employment bases near or below the national level of 8.8 percent. As shown in figure 3, the relationship between the relative size of the manufacturing employment base in 2010 and the post-2010 growth rates is fairly weak, although positive.3 In addition to Idaho, Florida, and Nevada mentioned above, North Dakota, Arizona, Colorado, Montana, and Georgia had strong growth given a relatively low starting base, although states such as Vermont, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Arkansas, Kansas, and Mississippi either continued to contract post 2010 or had slower-than-average growth in manufacturing employment even with a larger-than-average 2010 manufacturing employment base.

        Change in manufacturing employment since 2010 relative to starting manufacturing employment intensity level

        Figure 4 depicts the role manufacturing employment currently plays in state employment, in the aftermath of all of the disruption of the recession and a slow slog of a recovery. While there has been some movement of the rankings prior to the recession as compared to the present, the most striking fact is that in 2006, prior to the start of the recession, manufacturing accounted for more than 10 percent of total employment in 27 states; today, only 16 percent of states can make the same claim.

        Manufacturing employment as a percentage of total employment, July 2017

        Taking a global perspective

        The United States is not unique in transitioning from an economy where job creation is highly dependent on the manufacturing sector. Many other countries are heading in the same direction. As shown in figure 5,4 in some cases the shift has been more recent and in others the trend began around the same time as the transition began in the United States in the mid-1980s. For most countries, the rate of decline appears to have slowed or leveled off. There are two anomalies among the countries shown: The proportion of industry employment in Mexico has remained fairly level since 2000 and in China, the decline only began in 2013 after a period of strong growth over the prior 10 years.

        Employment in industry as a percentage of total employment

        Shifts in manufacturing’s employment intensity is only part of the manufacturing story. The contribution that manufacturing makes to an economy can also be evaluated by many other measures, such as the absolute amount of manufactured goods that an economy produces and the value added by the manufacturing sector as a percentage of gross domestic product. In addition to the direct jobs and output generated by manufacturing—and, maybe more importantly, to the health and innovative capacity of an economy—is the role that it plays in driving research and development investment, creation of intellectual property, and generation of productivity growth. Furthermore, every manufacturing facility supports an ecosystem of additional upstream and downstream jobs in other sectors such as services, construction, mining, and agriculture, as well as other manufacturing jobs. Therefore, even though manufacturing’s employment intensity will likely continue to decline, it will continue to be a critical component of economic growth, not only in the United States, but in most economies around the globe.

        Authors

        Patricia Buckley is the director of economic policy and analysis at Deloitte Research, and is based in Arlington, Virginia.

        Acknowledgements

        The author would like to thank Dr. Peter Viechnicki for providing technical assistance.

         

        Cover image by: Lucio Schiavon

        Endnotes
          1. All national-level data in this report has been calculated from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, “Current employment statistics—national level,” a survey of business establishments. View in article

          2. All state-level data in this report has been calculated from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, “Current employment statistics—state and metro level.” View in article

          3. The coefficient of correlation between the 2006 proportion of manufacturing employment to the growth rate from 2006 to 2017 is 30 percent—the higher the percentage, the more closely correlated the variables. View in article

          4. Manufacturing employment as a percentage of total employment was not available on a comparable basis for a wide selection of countries, therefore, figure 5 uses the indicator, “Employment in industry as a percentage of total employment,” as published by the World Bank and collected by the International Labor Organization. This is a broader measure and includes mining and quarrying (including oil production), construction, and public utilities (electricity, gas, and water), in addition to manufacturing. View in article

        Show moreShow less

        Topics in this article

        Behind the Numbers , Manufacturing , Manufacturing Competitiveness , United States (U.S.) , Americas

        Deloitte Consulting

        View
        Download Subscribe

        Related

        img Trending

        Interactive 3 days ago

        Share article highlights

        See something interesting? Simply select text and choose how to share it:

        Email a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
        Copy a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
        Copy your highlighted text.

        Geographic trends in manufacturing job creation: Something old, something new has been added to your bookmarks.

        Geographic trends in manufacturing job creation: Something old, something new has been removed from your bookmarks.

        An article titled Geographic trends in manufacturing job creation: Something old, something new already exists in the bookmark library

        Invalid special characters found 
        Forgot password

        OR

        Social login not available on Microsoft Edge browser at this time.

        Connect Accounts

        Connect your social accounts

        This is the first time you have logged in with a social network.

        You have previously logged in with a different account. To link your accounts, please re-authenticate.

        Log in with an existing social network:

        To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

        OR

        Log in with an existing site account:

        To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

        Forgot password

        Subscribe

        to receive more business insights, analysis, and perspectives from Deloitte Insights
        ✓ Link copied to clipboard
        • Contact us
        • Search jobs
        • Submit RFP
        • Subscribe to Deloitte Insights
        Follow Deloitte Insights:
        Global Office Directory
        US Office Locations
        Location: US-EN United States-English  
          About Deloitte
          • About us
          • My Deloitte
          • Deloitte Insights
          • Press releases
          • Social media
          • Email subscriptions
          • Submit RFP
          • US office locations
          • Alumni
          • Global office directory
          • Newsroom
          • CRG profiles
          • Dbriefs webcasts
          • Contact us

          Services

          • Tax
          • Consulting
          • Audit & Assurance
          • Deloitte Private Company Services
          • Mergers & Acquisitions
          • Risk & Financial Advisory
          • Analytics
          • Cloud

          Industries

          • Consumer
          • Energy, Resources & Industrials
          • Financial Services
          • Government & Public Services
          • Life Sciences & Health Care
          • Technology, Media & Telecommunications

          Careers

          • Careers
          • Students
          • Experienced Professionals
          • Job Search
          • Life at Deloitte
          • Alumni Relations
          • About Deloitte
          • Terms of Use
          • Privacy
          • Tax Privacy
          • Privacy Shield
          • Deloitte Digital Online Ad Privacy Policy
          • Cookies
          • Legal Information for Job Seekers
          • Labor Condition Applications

          © 2019. See Terms of Use for more information.

          Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee ("DTTL"), its network of member firms, and their related entities. DTTL and each of its member firms are legally separate and independent entities. DTTL (also referred to as "Deloitte Global") does not provide services to clients. In the United States, Deloitte refers to one or more of the US member firms of DTTL, their related entities that operate using the "Deloitte" name in the United States and their respective affiliates. Certain services may not be available to attest clients under the rules and regulations of public accounting. Please see www.deloitte.com/about to learn more about our global network of member firms.