Article
3 minute read 25 February 2021

Mobile networks are going virtual—and open

In the rollout of 5G service, open radio access networks (open RAN) promise lower deployment costs and faster innovation cycles

3 minute read 25 February 2021
Naima Hoque Essing

Naima Hoque Essing

United States

As providers roll out 5G, they are increasingly looking to open radio access networks—open RAN—for lower deployment costs and faster innovation cycles.

With the rapid growth of 5G intensifying demands on network capacity and equipment, mobile network operators (MNOs) are increasingly looking to new types of solutions. In particular, many MNOs are shifting away from their existing proprietary wireless networks to more open, standards-based, software-centric virtual platforms.

Because MNOs must replace or augment existing radio access and networking (RAN) equipment to deliver 5G service, the shift offers the opportunity to move away from closed, proprietary systems to adopt open and virtualized architectures (open RAN). Open RAN architectures enable equipment interoperability and multivendor RAN deployments; new entrants introduce competition that portend lower deployment costs and faster innovation cycles in the rollout of cellular services, including 5G.

As Deloitte’s TMT Predictions 2021 outlines in more detail, we expect open RAN implementations to double in 2021, from 35 active deployments in 2020.1 We anticipate that momentum will accelerate rapidly as the technology matures due to the logic of its network design and strategic alignment with carrier needs. Besides opening the RAN market to new vendors, open RAN promises to lower capital and operating costs and drive greater innovation, making rural technology deployments more economically feasible.

At this point, MNOs are focusing on second-tier markets—fully 60% of early open RAN deployments are currently located in developing markets, with another 20% in rural areas within developed markets.2 These observations are not wholly unexpected: MNOs are more likely to experiment with innovative new vendors and architectures in underserved areas, where the pressure for high performance and potential for stranded investment is lower. Moreover, relatively new and untried vendors are more likely to gain footholds in market scenarios where economic factors override service-level expectations. Comparatively low deployment costs make open RAN more economically feasible to enter or expand into underserved greenfield markets or rural areas with lower subscriber density.

While open RAN is gaining momentum worldwide, some operators remain skeptical—it offers many benefits, but the technology is still maturing, and there remain significant engineering and integration challenges. Open RAN also faces challenges in reaching performance parity with traditional systems, although that gap is rapidly closing. For now, issues affecting network performance and reliability are likely to give MNOs pause before introducing open RAN to core markets: The architecture’s scalability to larger networks with greater traffic loads and higher performance requirements remains unproven. Open RAN also requires a more hands-on approach by MNOs. Multivendor system integration, for example, is a significant challenge. The additional cost, time, and effort of validating new equipment vendors and testing compatible end-to-end network configurations could offset, if not completely negate, first-order benefits from vendor diversity. Understandably, some operators may prefer to postpone a potentially risky move and stick with traditional systems, in which they can look to a few trusted vendors to provide fully tested, carrier-grade solutions with turnkey deployment, maintenance, and integration support.3

As a result of these and other challenges, open RAN deployments have thus far been limited mainly to local and regional deployments. At this smaller scale, MNOs can more readily manage integration complexity and load on network functions. But as the technology matures, we anticipate more rapid acceleration in adoption and broader mass-scale deployments.

  1. Naima Hoque Essing et al., The next-generation radio access network: Open and virtualized RANs are the future of mobile networks , Deloitte Insights, December 7, 2020.View in Article
  2. Deloitte analysis uses developed and developing country designations as defined by MSCI Market Indices. MSCI, “MSCI announces the results of the 2020 annual market classification review ,” 2021.View in Article
  3. Essing et al., The next-generation radio access network.
    View in Article

 

The author would like to acknowledge Mathew Cherry for the data and analysis on which this charticle is based and also thank Dan Littmann, Allison Smith, and Tim Krause for their counsel and suggestions.

Cover image by: Viktor Koen

 

Technology, Media & Telecommunications

Deloitte’s Technology, Media & Telecommunications (TMT) industry practice brings together one

of the world’s largest group of specialists respected for helping shape many of the world’s most

recognized TMT brands—and helping those brands thrive in a digital world.

Paul Silverglate

Paul Silverglate

Leader | Deloitte US Technology Sector

Subscribe

to receive more business insights, analysis, and perspectives from Deloitte Insights