Deloitte Insights delivers proprietary research designed to help organizations turn their aspirations into action.

DELOITTE INSIGHTS

  • Home
  • Spotlight
    • Weekly Global Economic Outlook
    • Top 10 Reading Guide
    • Celebrating Earth Month
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Resilience
  • Topics
    • Strategy
    • Economy & Society
    • Operations
    • Workforce
    • Technology
  • Industries
    • Consumer
    • Energy, Resources, & Industrials
    • Financial Services
    • Government & Public Services
    • Life Sciences & Health Care
    • Technology, Media, & Telecom
  • More from Deloitte Insights
    • About
    • Deloitte Insights Magazine
    • Press Room Podcasts
Deloitte.com
Deloitte Insights logo
  • SPOTLIGHT
    • Weekly Global Economic Outlook
    • Top 10 Reading Guide
    • Celebrating Earth Month
    • Resilience
    • Artificial Intelligence
  • TOPICS
    • Strategy
    • Economy & Society
    • Operations
    • Workforce
    • Technology
  • INDUSTRIES
    • Consumer
    • Energy, Resources, & Industrials
    • Financial Services
    • Government & Public Services
    • Life Sciences & Health Care
    • Technology, Media,& Telecom
  • MORE FROM DELOITTE INSIGHTS
    • About
    • Deloitte Insights Magazine
    • Press Room Podcasts
  • Welcome!

    For personalized content and settings, go to your My Deloitte Dashboard

    Latest Insights

    Creating opportunity at the intersection of climate disruption and regulatory change

    Article
     • 
    7-min read

    Better questions about generative AI

    Article
     • 
    2-min read

    Recommendations

    Tech Trends 2025

    Article

    TMT Predictions 2025

    Article

    About Deloitte Insights

    About Deloitte Insights

    Deloitte Insights Magazine, issue 33

    Magazine

    Topics for you

    • Business Strategy & Growth
    • Leadership
    • Operations
    • Marketing & Sales
    • Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
    • Emerging Technologies
    • Economy

    Watch & Listen

    Dbriefs

    Stay informed on the issues impacting your business with Deloitte's live webcast series. Gain valuable insights and practical knowledge from our specialists while earning CPE credits.

    Deloitte Insights Podcasts

    Join host Tanya Ott as she interviews influential voices discussing the business trends and challenges that matter most to your business today. 

    Subscribe

    Deloitte Insights Newsletters

    Looking to stay on top of the latest news and trends? With MyDeloitte you'll never miss out on the information you need to lead. Simply link your email or social profile and select the newsletters and alerts that matter most to you.

Welcome back

To join via SSO please click on the key button below
Still not a member? Join My Deloitte

Oil’s well?: Divergence and imbalance in the oil and gas ecosystem

by Duane Dickson, Andrew Slaughter, Anshu Mittal
  • Save for later
  • Download
  • Share
    • Share on Facebook
    • Share on Twitter
    • Share on Linkedin
    • Share by email
8 minute read 23 April 2019

Oil’s well?: Divergence and imbalance in the oil and gas ecosystem Decoding the O&G downturn

8 minute read 23 April 2019
  • Duane Dickson United States
  • Andrew Slaughter United States
  • Anshu Mittal India
  • Save for later
  • Download
  • Share
    • Share on Facebook
    • Share on Twitter
    • Share on Linkedin
    • Share by email
  • Underperformance or divergence?
  • Imbalance within the O&G ecosystem …
  • … with a high regional variability in valuations
  • Employment and innovation have somewhat resisted the downturn
  • Lessons from the downturn

The past five years of low and volatile oil prices have shaken the entire O&G industry. From corporate strategies, operational performance, financial results, to even innovation and talent, companies are exploring new ways to adjust to the new normal.

After a difficult 2015 and 2016, the oil and gas (O&G) industry began showing signs of coming out of the woods by mid-2018, with oil prices recovering to US$85/bbl (Brent). Many industry executives appeared to regain confidence as their companies’ financials improved, resulting in growing optimism about 2019.1

Learn more

Create custom PDF or download the full report

Read all articles in the series—Decoding the O&G downturn

Browse the Oil, Gas & Chemicals collection

Read an article featuring these insights from Rigzone

Read an interview with Deloitte’s Andrew Slaughter

Read an article on this report from Oil & Gas Journal

Subscribe to receive related content

But then, oil prices surprised everyone by sliding more than 35 percent (Brent) to US$50/bbl in the last quarter of 2018.2 If fears of oversupply and the three largest oil producers (Russia, Saudi Arabia, and the United States) competing for market share weren’t enough, the rise in geopolitical tensions and concerns of a global economic slowdown seemed to have dented the positive momentum built over the past 12–18 months in the oil market. Although the downward slide has now been halted by the November agreement between OPEC and its allies to curb supplies by 1.2 million barrels per day (MMbbl/d), the steep fall amid heightened volatility marks five years of the collapse in oil prices from above US$100/bbl levels in 2014.3

How have O&G companies navigated the past five years of the downturn? Did the operational and capital adjustments of O&G companies translate into returns for investors? How have margins and value migrated between O&G segments? Which segment saw the highest fundamental–market divergence? Answering such questions could be essential to gain a complete perspective of the health and prospects of the O&G value chain.

Although many industry pundits have provided piecemeal perspectives across the phases of the downturn and recovery, a consolidated analysis of the past five years and a complete perspective covering the entire O&G value chain could help stakeholders—from executive to investor—make informed decisions for the uncertain future.

With this in mind, Deloitte analyzed 843 listed O&G companies worldwide across the four O&G segments (upstream, oilfield services, midstream, and refining & marketing) in an effort to gain a deeper and broader understanding of the industry. The ensuing research yielded a six-part series, Decoding the O&G downturn, which sets out to provide a big-picture reflection of the downturn and share our perspectives for consideration on the future.

In part one of the series, we explore the overall O&G industry—its market dynamics, the health of its segments, regional performance, and innovation and talent.

Underperformance or divergence?

In the pre-downturn period (2010–2013), the O&G industry commanded roughly 10 percent of listed companies’ market capitalization worldwide at around US$5 trillion (figure 1).4 By the end of 2018, this figure fell to 6 percent, with only two O&G companies in the top 25 companies of the world by market capitalization.5 The fall in the industry’s attractiveness has come at a time when the global economy expanded by 23 percent to US$70 trillion over the past five years.6

Undoubtedly, this reduced attractiveness of the industry is likely because of lower and volatile oil prices and weaker financials of O&G companies. However, the market seems to have disregarded recent efforts of O&G companies to drive capital efficiency in their projects and overall financials. For example, the industry’s return on capital, which hit lows of 2.7 percent in 2016, has recovered fast and is today close to pre-downturn levels even in a sub-US$65/bbl price environment (6.9 percent in 2018 as against 7.3 percent in 2013).7

Likewise, there has been far less appreciation of the fact that the industry maintained its higher-than-average dividend yield of 3.5 percent (as against 2.4 percent of other industries worldwide) even during the past five years of the downturn. The O&G industry returned more than US$720 billion in dividends between 2014 and 2018, the second highest after the financial services industry.8 In addition, share buyback programs also transferred cash to shareholders.

Although the market’s expectation of sustained weakness in oil prices could explain this bearish divergence, the industry’s continued emphasis on operational performance, shareholder distributions, and free cash flows should not be ignored for long—it has the potential to help it to win back investors’ trust in the times to come. In fact, the industry is estimated to generate more free cash flow in 2018 than it did in 2013 when a barrel of crude traded at an average of US$112/bbl.9

Which O&G segments have driven this divergence?

Imbalance within the O&G ecosystem …

A fit-for-future O&G industry needs a healthy ecosystem of producers, service providers, shippers, and processors and marketers. Without it, the gains of a recovery would likely go to a select few, while losses from a downturn could affect many, potentially impairing the ability of certain segments to attract capital and grow sustainably. While it’s normal for value and margins to migrate across the ecosystem, especially in a downturn, the migration in this downturn has been highly skewed and unhealthy for the most part. And this has been our big worry related to this downturn.

Although producers are recovering, and in some cases growing again, many in the oilfield services (OFS) segment continue to struggle for survival. For example, market capitalization of the OFS segment, which is the backbone for both shale growth and offshore revival, has fallen by half to US$262 billion and the entire segment is now less than the size of the biggest supermajor.10 In fact, currently, only one OFS company figures in the list of top 25 O&G companies worldwide by market capitalization (figure 2).

Conversely, operating margins in what have historically been the least lucrative O&G businesses, downstream and midstream, have shot up higher than what an average integrated producer and service company makes. For example, downstream margins of 6 percent are now higher than the 5 percent margins of a service company. Similarly, a midstream company’s fees/spread per unit of volume transferred has remained flat at a minimum, while the underlying commodity’s price has fallen by more than 50 percent during the downturn.11

Today’s lopsided producer–contractor–customer relationship, or the health of the O&G ecosystem, means that stabilization in the industry may still be a few years away, or that a big rationalization could play out.

… with a high regional variability in valuations

Unlike earnings, which have remained highly variable, the more stable, tangible assets provide a clearer picture of the industry’s performance and attractiveness. The industry has remained undervalued in general, with the market valuing O&G companies significantly below their book value or replacement cost at around 0.8 times (enterprise value/total assets, see figure 3).

At a regional level, however, EV/asset multiples have varied significantly despite O&G being a commoditized industry. In fact, there is 20–40 percent divergence in the valuation of companies/segments by regions. Although North America-based O&G companies have seen a fall of 10 percent in their valuation multiple, investors still generally value them close to their replacement cost. On the other hand, Latin American and European O&G companies have largely seen a flat to positive change in their valuations over 2013 levels.

Rising valuation disparity across segments and regions

Similarly, most private integrated oil companies (IOCs) and state-owned national oil companies (NOCs), especially outside North America, have received much lower valuation despite their stable integrated and/or diversified structure. On the other hand, OFS has turned into the least valued O&G segment, while the multiple of downstream companies worldwide hasn’t expanded like their margins over the past few years.

One can conclude that investors don’t seem to be buying into the O&G industry just to play price and margin cycles in pure-play businesses/regions or to park money in the safety of integrated structures. Although company-specific strategies and results that provide an upside beyond simple oil price increase could dictate investors’ interest, such high differences in valuations in an improved macro and oil price environment could set the stage for mega- and cross-regional M&A in the O&G industry.

Employment and innovation have somewhat resisted the downturn

The fall and heightened volatility in oil prices have troubled many executives, upset investors, and led to unforeseen migration of value and margins within the O&G industry. But what has been the impact of this downturn on innovation and the workforce in the industry? Did the downturn, along with automation, affect hiring in the industry? Did O&G companies favor a manufacturing and mass production mindset over technology- and data-led optimization?

Although the industry’s overall employment levels fell during the downturn, 2017 saw a recovery in headcount, and the current employment numbers of 4.5 million are only 1 percent below the 2013 numbers. The reason: About 300,000 layoffs in oilfield services, pure-play E&Ps, and private IOCs were largely offset by a hiring of 255,000 employees by NOCs and pure-play midstream and downstream companies (figure 4). Although redistribution of jobs between the segments/regions accelerated, especially those that are analytics-based, the industry’s volume growth and innovation seem to have supported overall employment by creating new and more work profiles.12

Similarly, the 16 percent fall in the industry’s research and development (R&D) expenditure to US$13.5 billion has been much less than its curtailment of capital expenditure. Impressively, the hardest-hit OFS segment maintained its R&D spending of US$3.4 billion and downstream registered its highest R&D spend in 2017. On the other hand, surprisingly, most large IOCs and NOCs have reduced their absolute R&D spend despite the established role of technology in lowering breakevens during the downturn. Although internally generated innovation is generally considered important, a balanced and united focus on innovation is also critical as organizations must often complement their internal innovation capabilities with solutions, ideas, and technologies from external partners and vendors.13

Lessons from the downturn

The lower-for-longer environment seems to have shaped the industry in its own unique way, and is likely to continue to do so in the near future. Although company-specific strategies that provide an upside beyond oil price and generate sustainable efficiencies will often determine investors’ interest, a few pointers could help the industry to respond favorably to the new reality:

  • O&G companies with fit-for-future portfolios should effectively position themselves as a strong value/yield investment and strongly talk about their progress in growing free cash flows, maintaining shareholder distributions, and increasing their ROC to investors.14
  • Advantaged segments and players should bring a balance to today’s lopsided contractual relationships by sharing in the economics of efficiencies created by contractors and vendors, thus providing a win–win relationship.
  • O&G companies across the value chain should stay invested in harnessing capabilities of the new-age workforce and remain open to accelerated innovation happening outside the industry as well.

Volatility has always been the name of the game in the O&G industry. However, the past five years have forced many companies to rethink their strategies. A strong understanding of the downturn could therefore help companies determine where to play and how to win. In the next few articles, we will examine all O&G segments through the lens of the downturn. Explore the entire Decoding the O&G downturn series to understand how you can thrive amid uncertainty.

Acknowledgments

A number of leaders and colleagues within Deloitte member firms generously contributed their time and insights to this report. In no particular order, the authors would like to thank Rajeev Chopra (partner, Deloitte Global), Michael Lynn (partner, Deloitte Australia), and Roland Labuhn (partner, Deloitte Canada) for their review and contributions to this research.

We would also like to extend our special thanks to John England (partner, Deloitte US) and Scott Sanderson (partner, Deloitte US) for their perspectives and suggestions on the entire series. Thanks also to Rithu Thomas (editor), Sharene Williams (chief of staff), Jennifer McHugh (OG&C sector specialist), Joanna Lambeas (marketer), Dana Kruse (marketer), Mindy Porter (marketer), and Laurel McConn (marketer) for providing valuable inputs, extensive marketing support, and critical editorial help at important junctures.

Cover image by: Swagata Samanta

Endnotes
    1. Deloitte, 2018 oil, gas, and chemicals industry executive survey—A look at the trends shaping the future of the industry, 2018. View in article

    2. Energy Information Administration, US Department of Energy. View in article

    3. International Energy Agency, Oil market report, December 13, 2018. View in article

    4. Based on Deloitte’s analysis of 843 O&G companies listed worldwide with market capitalization of more than US$50 million (data from Capital IQ). View in article

    5. Ibid. View in article

    6. Based on all listed companies’ data on Capital IQ. View in article

    7. Ibid. View in article

    8. Based on Deloitte’s industry classification and data from Capital IQ. View in article

    9. Ibid. View in article

    10. Ibid. View in article

    11. Ibid. View in article

    12. Rumki Majumdar and Anshu Mittal, How the shale revolution is reshaping the US oil and gas labor landscape, Deloitte Insights, September 19, 2018. View in article

    13. Regien Sumo, Jaap Kalkman, and Arjan van Weele, Innovation through contracting in the oil and gas sector, Arthur D. Little, April 2018. View in article

    14. Andrew Slaughter, Anshu Mittal, and Vivek Bansal, The portfolio predicament: How can upstream oil and gas companies build a fit-for-the-future portfolio?, Deloitte Insights, April 10, 2018. View in article

Show moreShow less

Topics in this article

Power & Utilities , Center for Energy & Industrials , Energy, Resources, & Industrials

Digital Oil, Gas & Chemicals

With its breadth of experience in working across the crude oil and natural gas value chain, Deloitte helps clients anticipate the changing landscape and take advantage of emerging opportunities. Deloitte can help clients uncover data-driven insights to inform vision, strategy, and decision making; provide insight into current and shaping trends; assist executives in delivering value to their shareholders; drive operational excellence and prudent capital management across a company; identify, analyze, and perform due diligence for acquisition opportunities; transform business models to capture new growth opportunities; and apply technologies to achieve business goals. Reach out to any of the contacts listed at the end of this document for more information.

Learn more
Get in touch
Contact
  • Andrew Slaughter
  • Executive director
  • Deloitte Services LP
  • anslaughter@deloitte.com
  • +1 713 982 3526

Download Subscribe

Related content

img Trending

Interactive 3 days ago

More insights for Oil, Gas & Chemicals

  • From bytes to barrels Article7 years ago
  • Refining at risk Article7 years ago
  • Following the capital trail in oil and gas Article10 years ago
  • A renaissance in the domestic oil and gas industry Article11 years ago
  • Global renewable energy trends Article6 years ago
Duane Dickson

Duane Dickson

Principal | Deloitte Consulting LLP

Duane Dickson has more than 38 years of business and consulting experience in senior leadership positions in major industrial and health care products companies. Dickson is based out of Stamford, Connecticut and serves as a principal in Deloitte Consulting LLP’s Energy, Resources & Industrials group, as well as vice chairman, US Oil, Gas & Chemicals sector leader, and the Global Chemicals & Specialty Materials Consulting leader.

  • rdickson@deloitte.com
  • +1 203 979 2300
Andrew Slaughter

Andrew Slaughter

Executive Director | Center for Energy Solutions

As an executive director for the Deloitte Center for Energy Solutions, Deloitte Services LP, Andrew works closely with Deloitte’s Energy, Resources & Industrials leadership to define, implement, and manage the execution of the Center strategy; develop and drive energy research initiatives; and manage the development of the Center’s eminence and thought leadership. During his 25 year career as an oil and gas leader, he occupied senior roles in both major oil, gas, and chemicals companies and consulting/advisory firms.

  • anslaughter@deloitte.com
  • + 1 713 982 3526
Anshu Mittal

Anshu Mittal

Research leader, oil & gas | Deloitte Support Services India Private Limited

Anshu Mittal is a vice president in Deloitte’s Research & Insights team and US-India office’s Research & Insights leader. With nearly 20 years of experience in the energy and resources industry, he has advised governments and companies on policy-, regulatory-, strategy-, and transaction-level issues across the energy value chain.

  • ansmittal@deloitte.com
  • +91 990 854 9995

Share article highlights

See something interesting? Simply select text and choose how to share it:

Email a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
Copy a customized link that shows your highlighted text.
Copy your highlighted text.

Oil’s well?: Divergence and imbalance in the oil and gas ecosystem has been saved

Oil’s well?: Divergence and imbalance in the oil and gas ecosystem has been removed

An Article Titled Oil’s well?: Divergence and imbalance in the oil and gas ecosystem already exists in Saved items

Invalid special characters found 
Forgot password

To stay logged in, change your functional cookie settings.

OR

Social login not available on Microsoft Edge browser at this time.

Connect Accounts

Connect your social accounts

This is the first time you have logged in with a social network.

You have previously logged in with a different account. To link your accounts, please re-authenticate.

Log in with an existing social network:

To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

OR

Log in with an existing site account:

To connect with your existing account, please enter your password:

Forgot password

Subscribe

to receive more business insights, analysis, and perspectives from Deloitte Insights
✓ Link copied to clipboard

Deloitte Insights delivers proprietary research designed to help organizations turn their aspirations into action.

Deloitte Insights

  • Home
  • Topics
  • Industries
  • About Deloitte Insights

Spotlight

  • Weekly Global Economic Outlook
  • Top 10 Reading Guide
  • Celebrating Earth Month
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Resilience
Deloitte logo

Learn about Deloitte’s offerings, people, and culture as a global provider of audit, assurance, consulting, financial advisory, risk advisory, tax, and related services.

  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy
  • Privacy Shield
  • Cookies
  • Legal Information for Job Seekers
  • Labor Condition Applications
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information