Elevating the digital payments experience has been saved
Perspectives
Elevating the digital payments experience
Unlock deeper financial relationships through payments modernization
Consumers have come to expect digital-first experiences at every interaction. The card payments journey shouldn’t be the exception. Discover how five modern card issuing functionalities can help issuers reimagine the digital payments process to enhance customer experiences and loyalty, empower better money management, and deliver compounding value.
Building the case for payments modernization
In June 2019, Bank of America debuted its digital debit card in the United States, allowing customers to apply for a new or replacement card in its mobile banking app—getting it issued instantly in the app itself. Digitally issued cards give customers instant access to their funds for digital and contactless in-person payments and allow the issuer to address fraud associated with in-branch card issuance.
Nearly three years later, the COVID-19 pandemic has only strengthened the case for digital issuance across the industry. Digital card issuance is a natural extension of the convenient and instant access to funds that consumers have begun to expect. And according to Mastercard’s COVID Consumer Impact Tracker, 57% of respondents believe receiving and using digital cards over physical cards is a change that’s here to stay.
But digital issuance is only the first step. Modern card issuing, or payments modernization, is an open application programming interface (API) based approach to reimagining the card payments experience that not only supports instant digital issuance but can also facilitate smoother card integration with third-party programs. This integration can allow issuers to offer greater personalization and tighter spend controls to customers. Payments modernization can lay the groundwork for issuers to give consumers what they expect today while also positioning them to meet consumers’ latent needs, whether it’s their interest to buy now, pay later (BNPL) in installments, or earn crypto or stock rewards.
To test this hypothesis, we conducted a survey to explore consumers’ interest in payment features that can be powered by modern card issuing and its impact on their overall financial relationships. Our survey indicates that two-thirds of surveyed cardholders said they’d expand their relationship with an institution that invests in elevating their payments experience and their preferred features and functions.
About the survey
Deloitte conducted a consumer payments survey between August and September 2021 to gauge consumers’ interest in the experiences powered by a modern card issuing platform.The survey was fielded to 1,947 US banked or underbanked consumers by an independent research firm. In this report, we focus on four generations of consumers: Generation Z: ages 18–23; millennials: ages 24–39; Generation X: ages 40–55; baby boomers+: ages 56 and above. Younger respondents (Gen Z and millennials) comprised 60% of the sample. All data presented in this report is unweighted.
The survey and resulting report have been prepared in collaboration with Marqeta.
Giving a modern makeover to consumers’ card payment journey
Consumers have multiple touchpoints in their card payments experience, including application, onboarding, payment transactions, rewards accumulation and redemption, debt management, and chargebacks. While smartphones have digitized the way we pay, the touchpoints before and after the core payment transaction are prime for a digital makeover.
Using these touchpoints as prompts, we asked cardholders in our survey to choose their top three preferred functionalities that would elevate their overall digital payments experience. While the list is not meant to be comprehensive, it’s indicative of the desires of consumers that payments modernization can provide. A careful look at five functionalities in particular indicates that while all of them add value to the consumer digital payments journey individually, they can create much more powerful experiences when used together.
Eliminate the waiting time
Applying for a new or replacement card can be a painful experience if the issuer’s infrastructure is burdened by legacy processes, paper-based applications, and manual delays. A new credit card from a large issuer typically takes about 7–10 business days, while a replacement card takes anywhere from 3–7 days. This waiting time doesn’t bode well for younger consumers who prefer speed in service and delivery.
In this regard, digital card issuance is a meaningful solution, wherein a card is instantly issued in a mobile wallet or an app; of course, customers can also request a physical card if they’d prefer one in their tangible wallets. Consumers see value in instant digital issuance, with 44% of those surveyed selecting it as one of their top three functionalities.
Break free from the days of manually adding card details
Easy card integration goes hand in hand with digital issuance. Imagine consumers getting a digital card issued instantly but having to manually save their card details on all their go-to shopping apps, media streaming apps, yoga and meditation apps, food ordering apps, and mobile wallets—one at a time. Why can’t integration to third-party apps be more intuitive?
One-half of our surveyed customers would prefer the ease of automatically saving their cards on third-party apps and wallets over manually entering their payment details, even if it’s only for the first time. The ability to push the card directly to a wallet could provide immediate access and ability to spend funds, whether digitally or in person.
Issuers are taking note and starting with one-to-one integrations. American Express launched an app-to-app integration with PayPal in October 2021, which allows customers to directly save their Amex cards on PayPal with the click of a button. Payments modernization expedites this process and uses integration into APIs to allow issuers to connect with multiple third-party apps and wallets at scale. Unquestionably, data security is a baseline requirement underpinning such integrations.
Impress customers with smarter rewards
Who doesn’t like to be rewarded for loyalty? But while rewards have always played a significant role in the value proposition of credit cards—and more recently debit cards—adding a personalized touch can make customers feel special. Two-in-five surveyed customers would prefer personalized rewards over fixed rewards.
Legacy infrastructure can impede issuers’ ability to deliver on customers’ expectations on personalization. But payments modernization can allow customers to choose the rewards of their choice, whether it’s in the form of cashback, statement credits, shares, or cryptocurrency.
Moreover, the technology underpinning modern card issuing can enable incumbent issuers to automate the process of identifying customers’ favorite spending categories based on their shopping transactions. This way cardholders don’t have to worry about manually selecting their preferred rewards categories and can trust they will get rewarded for spending on categories most relevant to them.
Help consumers get better control over their finances
In our survey, one-in-five cardholders would prefer to have more control over their finances. In a digital world, the ability to dynamically set limits and alerts on transaction types, geolocations, and amounts could mitigate the risk of fraudulent card activity and make consumers feel in control of their spending and card debt. In addition, giving customers a clearer view of their spending could empower them to make better budgeting decisions and allow issuers to push more relevant insights on money management.
The entry of leading payment networks with their digital card programs is an encouraging validation to the trend. When Mastercard launched its Digital-First Card Program in 2019, it embarked on a journey to reposition digital credit cards from just a payment instrument to a means to better money management. To achieve its goal, the payment network has been onboarding several payment processors on its guidelines to digitize cardholders’ life cycle, from application and issuance to data reporting and controls. These processors, in turn, would work with interested card issuers to enable near-instant digital card issuance integrated with built-in controls on transaction limits and spending.
Give customers more choice to pay as they wish
US cardholders, especially younger consumers, are looking for choice and flexibility as core tenets of their payments experience. The growth of the BNPL industry is a testament to this expectation.
Over one-half of Gen Z and millennial cardholders in our survey used at least one BNPL product in the past year, more than double compared to Gen X and boomer BNPL users. Moreover, the use of BNPL options isn’t limited to consumers who don’t have access to credit or who don’t prefer to use credit cards. In our survey, 40% of customers who consider credit cards as their primary card have also used BNPL financing in the past year.
While many card issuers are entering the BNPL space by launching their separate offerings, some customers find a bundled product more appealing. One-fifth of our surveyed consumers would like the optionality to BNPL, pay instantly, or roll over the balance at a transaction level, and a card that bundles these funding options together in an integrated offering can give customers that choice.
Creating value beyond cards can unlock deeper financial relationships
The core value of payments modernization is to build digital payment experiences that are simpler and more convenient. And institutions that ace this experience design and delivery can not only win customers’ trust but also strengthen loyalty. While the overarching ambition for issuers to expand their customer relationship beyond cards is not new, modern card issuing perhaps lends a fresh perspective to achieve the goal. In our survey, about two-thirds of customers agree they will expand product holding with the institution that elevates their overall experience by offering their preferred payments functionalities. Issuers have an exciting opportunity to elevate their role and meet customers’ broader financial needs. What key strategic considerations can help them seize it?
- Strengthening customer-centricity to build seamless and intuitive experiences
- Using creative marketing campaigns to educate customers on the modern functionalities and how they can make it easier for customers to manage money
- Implementing laser-focused execution on top of existing technology stacks
- Partnering with payment processors in the ecosystem who share the same overall goals
- Integrating with different players in the ecosystem, including new merchants
Seize the opportunities that come with payments modernization
Issuers should strategically assess modern card issuing features that are of interest to consumers and collaborate with the right partners to bring those to market, both with agility and at scale. While some issuers may adopt a wait-and-watch approach, those with strategic acumen, technology foresight, and an execution mindset can seize the opportunity to empower their customers and strengthen loyalty.
If you’d like to learn more about modern card issuing and how your business can tap into its current opportunities, let’s chat.
Recommendations
Getting ahead of the curve
Learn how and why the credit card market needs to evolve to meet changing customer needs and expectations.
Internal Audit in the payments industry
Explore the shifting landscape in digital payments trends